When Hall & Oates, touring in support of their 2006 album Home for Christmas, launched into the first night of their two-day run at the Beacon Theater with “The First Noel,” the audience was into it. Ladies in the next row over from us seemed about ready to toss their underwear onstage as the King of Israel was born. But after about five such holiday songs, restlessness set in. There were screams for “Maneater.” Suburbanites loudly threatened to catch the next train out of Penn Station if they heard one more carol. And that wasn't the worst of it: Half of the balcony booed when Daryl Hall asked if we were feeling the holiday spirit. Much of the audience came purely for the greatest hits, and they weren't afraid to shit on Hall, Oates, or baby Jesus to get it. When the band did start delivering the classics, the crowd warmed right up, doing a “Private Eyes” — CLAP! — “are watching you” — CLAP CLAP! — sing-along and pumping their fists to “Rich Girl.” The band, possibly out of spite, did not play “Maneater.” —Elizabeth Black
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
The Complete History of XXXTentacion’s Controversial Career
The Handmaid’s Tale Recap: Brief Encounter
Younger’s Peter Hermann on That Long-Awaited Confrontation Scene
What Is the Gayest Marvel Movie?
Comedians Reveal What the L.A. Stand-up Scene Actually Pays
Hannah Gadsby Decided to Quit Comedy, and Then Her Career Blew Up
Amy Adams Stood Up for Her Stand-in on the Sharp Objects Set
The Complicated Life and Death of XXXTentacion
I Ate a Home-cooked Italian Feast With the Jersey Shore Cast
The Bachelorette’s Big, Ugly Casting Problem
Latest News from VultureSpringsteen Interrupted His Broadway Show to Slam Trump’s ‘Disgracefully Inhumane and Un-American’ Border Policy
“May God save our souls.”Trial & Error Season Two Trailer: Kristin Chenoweth, Murderer?
Meet Lavinia Peck-Foster, icon.Minnie Driver Really, Really Wishes She Could Sing More Often
The Speechless star is dreaming of an all-musical episode for season three.The Best of Antoni Not Cooking on Queer Eye Season Two
In season two, Queer Eye food expert Antoni is a source of delightful background comedy.Queer Eye’s Antoni Is Opening a ‘Fast-Casual Food Concept’ in New York City
For the hungry boy.Watch a Doll Version of Steve Carell Fight Off Nazis in the Welcome to Marwen Trailer
This looks so heartwarming.Just 3 Minutes and 52 Seconds of Ariana Grande Frolicking in a Forest With Her Clones
What the hell is this video?How to Clean a Dinosaur at NYC’s Museum of Natural History
You’ll need a jet pack, a crane, and a can-do attitude.Chemistry? Watch Sheila Carrasco and Eliot Schwartz in Piano Lessons
They’re the Marty and Bobbi Mohan-Culp of 2018.What Is the Gayest Marvel Movie?
We ranked them, honey.
“Depression is a tenacious and scary condition.”Watch Nick Offerman and Kiersey Clemons Jam in This Hearts Beat Loud Music Video
Hearts Beat Loud is in theaters now.Queer Eye Recap: Man of the Hour
The Fab Five make over a trans man who’s trying to look his best (and who really needs to lose the “cat pee couch”).Cardi B Calls Trump a ‘Madman’ and a ‘Dickhead’
She also has thoughts on impeachment.Josh Brolin Will Star in Hulu’s ‘The Untitled Josh Brolin Project’
Yes, that’s really the title.Amy Adams Stood Up for Her Stand-in on the Sharp Objects Set
“I went into producer [mode] and I was like, ‘You will not handle her like that.’”Mandy Moore on This Is Us, Sad TV, and Touring With ‘N Sync
Plus, her memories of touring with ’N Sync in the ’90s.Comedians Reveal What the L.A. Stand-up Scene Actually Pays
“The idea that you can just move here and start making five figures doing stand-up comedy is the best joke I’ve heard all year.”Report: Cops Use Tear Gas on Crowd at XXXTentacion Memorial
Police in riot gear were on the scene.Creed II Trailer: Boxing, Babies, and, Hallelujah, Michael B. Jordan’s Arms!
We missed them.