Nada Surf should have felt perfectly at home playing the first of two sold-out gigs kicking off the tour for their new album, Lucky: Half of the thirtysomethings filling the Music Hall of Williamsburg were probably the Brooklyn group’s friends, after all, and the audience was warm and attentive. But warmth and attentiveness isn’t what hometown shows by beloved bands are about — boisterousness and ardor are. The crowd seemed a little like they had their minds on the babysitters back home. Singer Matthew Caws, who lives a short way from the venue, even went so far as to say that he felt like the show could’ve been happening on “Any Street, USA.” And so it was a testament to the guys onstage that near the end of a set that tended toward the tender, melancholy, and beautiful, the folks in attendance finally seemed pumped, taking a cue to sing along and even launching a few fists in the air. Apparently heart-on-sleeve and balls-out can co-exist after all. —Julia Simon
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Gun Advocate Wrote a 1,400-Word Recap About Getting Duped by Sacha Baron Cohen
Younger Recap: What Happens on Shelter Island …
Who Has the Most Damning Appearance on Who Is America?
Every Rob Reiner Movie, Ranked
Kate Winslet, Diane Keaton, and Mia Wasikowska Team Up to Break Your Heart
Stephen Colbert Calls Trump–Putin Summit ‘Treason’ and Other Reactions From Late-Night Hosts
50 Cent on Making Fun of Terry Crews’s Sexual Assault: ‘I Would Never Make Fun of Any Sexual-Assault Victim’
Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again Is All Blue Skies
The Handmaid’s Tale Season-Finale Recap: Beginnings and Endings
Below Deck Mediterranean Recap: Breakdowns!
Latest News from VultureCiara Levels Up The Moves In New Video
Come see how silly your little #squadgoals are.Watch Charlie Puth Sing Your Favorite 90’s Punk Songs
And “Wannabe” by the Spice Girls for good measure.Jimmy Kimmel Wants a Chimpanzee President Because Why Not
It’s not like it could possibly be any more ridiculous.Kate Winslet, Diane Keaton, and Mia Wasikowska Team Up to Break Your Heart
Apparently they don’t think we’ve had enough.Younger Recap: What Happens on Shelter Island …
Gina Gershon guest stars as a rock star with a tell-all in an episode that brings Liza and Charles closer together.Below Deck Mediterranean Recap: Breakdowns!
Everyone’s a mess this week. More than a mess than usual, even.Mr. Big Backs Cynthia Nixon’s Campaign For Governor
Christopher Noth isn’t the first “Sex and the City” star to back Nixon.Black Panther’s Shuri Is Getting Her Own Spin-Off Comic From Writer Nnedi Okorafor
“What are thooooooose?”Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants Is Being Tailored Into a Stage Musical
A chance for everyone to belt.The Bold Type Recap: The Shooting Club
Jane’s kind of awful to everyone in an episode that cautiously delves into the issue of guns.
“I’m looking at the Hulk, the guy that’s this big being taken advantage of.”Nicole Byer and Jacques Torres on What You Don’t See on Nailed It!
Netflix cuts out all the really dirty jokes.Gun Advocate Wrote a 1,400-Word Recap About Getting Duped by Sacha Baron Cohen
Posted back in February.8 Sexy Courtroom Shows to Stream Now That Your Interest in Suits Has Waned
Allow James Spader to fill the void.Tom Cruise Learns How to Do Finger Hearts
Thank you, Simon Pegg!Lauren Lapkus Is the World’s Biggest Episodes Fan
“I love it so much but I have no one to talk to about it.”Taron Egerton Is Shirtless and Inspiring the People in the Robin Hood Trailer
He’s taking on a very cranky Ben Mendelsohn.Here’s a Casting Breakdown for RuPaul’s Netflix Show
RuPaul will play a “bigger-than-life but down-on-her-luck” drag queen.Steven Soderbergh: ‘Those Bad ’90s Movies Were Necessary for My Development’
“In my mind, this was all part of the process that I had to go through.”Every Rob Reiner Movie, Ranked
A few good films.