Nada Surf should have felt perfectly at home playing the first of two sold-out gigs kicking off the tour for their new album, Lucky: Half of the thirtysomethings filling the Music Hall of Williamsburg were probably the Brooklyn group’s friends, after all, and the audience was warm and attentive. But warmth and attentiveness isn’t what hometown shows by beloved bands are about — boisterousness and ardor are. The crowd seemed a little like they had their minds on the babysitters back home. Singer Matthew Caws, who lives a short way from the venue, even went so far as to say that he felt like the show could’ve been happening on “Any Street, USA.” And so it was a testament to the guys onstage that near the end of a set that tended toward the tender, melancholy, and beautiful, the folks in attendance finally seemed pumped, taking a cue to sing along and even launching a few fists in the air. Apparently heart-on-sleeve and balls-out can co-exist after all. —Julia Simon
Most Viewed Stories
George Takei Calmly Dismantles All of Marvel’s Excuses for Its Doctor Strange Casting
10 Strange Stories From Ron Miscavige’s Scientology Tell-all Ruthless
All the Ways Game of Thrones’ Ramsay Bolton Is Way Worse in the Books
While His Peers Took Chances, Drake Doubled Down on Drake
Jay Z’s Reportedly Responding to Lemonade With an Album, Because He Has Feelings, Too
‘I Just Don’t Find American Literature Interesting’: Lit-Blog Pioneer Jessa Crispin Closes Bookslut, Does Not Bite Tongue
Spoiler Alert: This Is a Post About Spoiler Etiquette
Patton Oswalt Eulogizes His Wife, Michelle McNamara: ‘She’s Left a Blast Crater’
Woody Allen: Changing Soon-Yi’s Life Has Been One of His Greatest Pleasures
Blake Lively Stars in a New Trailer for The Shallows, Which Is Basically Her The Revenant
Latest News from VultureWhat an Iraq Vet Sees in the Recent HBO War Documentary, Only the Dead
Military culture as seen from the far shore of civilian world.A Festivalgoer’s Guide to the Real Cannes
Everything to know about the city: what Cannois are talking about (rats, Russians), where to spot stars, and the best place for a 3 a.m. blowout.Donald Trump Fake-Calls Barack Obama on The Tonight Show to Gloat About the Indiana Outcome; On a Scale of 1-10, How Scared Are You?
Help.Gwen Stefani Carpool Karaoke: She Is Not Alone — George Clooney and Julia Roberts Are Also Here
The No Doubt co-founder did her best emoji impersonations for The Late Late Show host — and, yeah, sang with a pretty full car.Justin Timberlake Reveals New Song Title; Said Song Comes Out This Friday
TGIAF.Magic Mike Is Doing a Vegas Show — a.k.a. Live Hip-Thrusting
Doin' it live, starting March 2017.Black-ish Recap: Wealthy Lives Matter
Dre's insecurities about manhood are getting old. Black-ish needs to mix it up.The Americans Recap: The Pursuit of Happiness
What does it mean to be an American?The Last Panthers Recap: The Day of Execution
This is a story about people who cannot let go of the past.The Americans Showrunners on Season 4’s Biggest Episode Yet
And why we may yet see a musical episode of The Americans.
The last two episodes are among the best hours the show has produced.How Is Martha Doing on The Americans?
"On The Americans, as in life, when you’re not dead, there’s always hope."Underground Recap: Devil’s Snare
The Hawkses' safehouse isn't freedom. It's purgatory.DEA, U.S. Attorney’s Office Officially Join Prince Investigation [Updated]
"They have agreed to provide federal resources and expertise."The Real Housewives of New York City Recap: Run the Jules
Hear ye, hear ye! A judgement shall be passed on Jules Wainstein.Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Season Finale Recap: Coasting to Victory
Kimmy finally confronts her neglectful mom.That Game of Thrones Scene Was Awkward for Kit Harington and Carice van Houten, Too
Kit Harington called the experience "like a teenage boy’s wet dream."Seth MacFarlane Is Bringing His Face to TV in a Live-Action Sci-fi Series
The series is set 300 years in the future.What Happened to All of The Good Wife’s Lost Characters?
It’s time to speculate.Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt Recap: Drinking Problems
In a show that's unafraid to let its characters grow, Dr. Andrea is the stuck exception.