The casting of Robert Downey Jr. as Iron Man isn't just a grotesque affront to Iron Man fans. After all, who care about Iron Man fans? They're a minority even among comic-book geeks. No, having an effeminate roué like Robert Downey Jr. play Tony Stark is actually the most subversive thing that's ever been done in a comic-book movie — and not in a good way. Tony Stark, the billionaire industrialist who wears the Iron Man suit, is among the most virile of all superhero alter egos; if not for his bum ticker, he would make Bruce Wayne look like a milquetoast. Instead, the casting of Downey makes us fear the movie presents an ironic, effete weakling hidden inside the suit — the very image of "man, half dead in his accoutrements." Like Darth Vader, whose fearsome mask hides a pale and puckered scalp, RDJ as Tony Stark is a secret shame, a supercilious weakling hidden inside a suit that every scene of the movie will pronounce to be a fraud. If we were in a forgiving mood, we'd suggest that director Jon Favreau was making a point about the Zeitgeist, or the weakness of modern man, but that doesn't matter: The iron glove should never contain a velvet hand. —Josh Ozersky
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Analyzing the Crazy, Complicated Credits of Avengers: Infinity War
America’s Next Top Model Recap: Undercover B*tch
On My Block Is a Remarkable Coming-of-Age Story
The Cold War Is Over
What’s New on Netflix: March 2018
Fifth Harmony’s Successor Should Be Little Mix
Ringo Starr Finally Got Knighted, So Who’s Laughing Now, Quincy Jones?
Cynthia Nixon Is Running for Office, But Some Can Only See Miranda Hobbes
Every Episode of Black Mirror, Ranked From Worst to Best
Ricky Gervais: Humanity Needs an Empathy Lesson
Latest News from VultureWhy Isn’t Rosie Perez’s Character in Charge on Rise?
Miss Wolfe had an idea for Grease!Snoop Dogg’s New Gospel Album, Bible of Love, Is Surprisingly Great
It’s a warm, wise survey of gospel music’s past, present, and possible future that works better than it should.I Kill Giants’ Rocky, Emotional Road to the Screen
The comic it was based on came from joy and sorrow.Tessa Thompson Is the Personal Trainer of Your Dreams in Portlandia’s Series Finale
Carrie Brownstein catches Tessa’s eye.Please Send Your Heartfelt Condolences to Henry Cavill, Who Shaved His Mission: Impossible Mustache
*Frowns in Justice League.*Laura Benanti Points Out the One Thing You Have in Common With Melania Trump
We’re more similar than you think.The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills Recap: Psychic Sidekick
Let us pause to mourn the loss of Lisa Vanderpump’s dog.Under the Silver Lake Trailer: Andrew Garfield Gets Caught in a Big Stoner-Noir L.A. Mystery
From the guy who brought you It Follows.The Temptations, Sound of Music, Fleetwood Mac, Boogie Into the Library of Congress’s Music Registry
The 25 “culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant” titles added to the National Recording Registry this year.Every Steven Soderbergh Movie, Ranked From Worst to Best
As Unsane hits theaters, we evaluate every Soderbergh film, from Solaris to Schizopolis.
As a director, Tucci appears to savor the step-by-step process of creation from both his characters and his actors, Armie Hammer and Geoffrey Rush.Love, Simon? Don’t Love, Simon?: A Debate on the Little Gay Movie That Could
Matt Rogers and Bowen Yang weigh in on the Queer Twitter Drama surrounding the queer romantic comedy-drama.The Cold War Is Over
They aren’t as sad about the end of their show as you might think.Watching Jimmy Kimmel Get a Colonoscopy Is Soothing, in Its Way
Katie Couric cheers him on, 18 years after she televised her own procedure.Olivia de Havilland and FX Debate Whether ‘Bitch’ Is Worse Than ‘Dragon Lady’ in Court
This is turning out to be a real dragon lady of a lawsuit.Let Them Be Your Stars Again: NBC’s Smash Could Get a Stage Reboot
Fade in a TV revival.Syfy’s Nightflyers Trailer: George R.R. Martin Presents … Space
“It’s Psycho in space.” Well, don’t mind if we do.America’s Next Top Model Recap: Undercover B*tch
Never underestimate Top Model in doing wrong by its contestants.Rise Recap: Totally Effed
How is this show on Mr. Mazzu’s side?Ringo Starr Finally Got Knighted, So Who’s Laughing Now, Quincy Jones?
The Beatle received his honor from Prince William at Buckingham Palace on Tuesday.