If Alison Pill is supposed to be the ugly girl in Neil LaBute's new play, Reasons to Be Pretty, is there really any reason for the rest of us to even try? When director Terry Kinney sent her the script, she told us at last night's opening-night party, "I read it and I went, Oh, thanks a lot, Terry. Great, I'm the ugly chick." That wasn't the first time that a role made her a little self-conscious about her looks, though; Pill told us that on the set of Dan in Real Life, the makeup artist put Whitestrips on her teeth without a word. "I thought it was normal until I asked the rest of the cast, and they said, 'No, I have no idea what you're talking about.' It was horrifying. I just kept thinking, Oh well, I guess my teeth are horrible to look at. Eventually I did it on my own at home." Now, in her role as the so-called ugly girl, Pill says she's been receiving not only great reviews — including a flat-out rave in this morning's Times — but lots of people coming up to her and reassuring her that she is, in fact, very pretty. "It goes to the heart of everyone's insecurities, including my own, and they're easy lines to say because Neil has written a girl who has the same questions that every woman has of how they're perceived by the outside world," she said. "So I mean, I didn't actually say to [Kinney], 'So you think I'm ugly?' I just kind of avoided that question." —Nina Mandell
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Olympic Figure Skater Brushes Off ‘Nightmare’ Wardrobe Malfunction
Charlyne Yi Claims Marilyn Manson Harassed ‘Just About Every Woman’ While Visiting House Set
Can You Suppress Your Reaction to Fergie’s NBA All-Star National Anthem?
Kris Jenner Would Apparently Complain to E! About The Soup’s Kardashian Jokes Back in the Day
In Conversation: Quincy Jones
Every Episode of Black Mirror, Ranked From Worst to Best
What’s New on Netflix: February 2018
Can You Revise a Book to Make It More Woke?
Tara Lipinski, Johnny Weir, and Leslie Jones Teach a Master Class in Jamming to Beyoncé
Fergie Says She ‘Tried Her Best’ With That Risk-Taking National Anthem
Latest News from VultureNew Terrence Malick Spinoff Has Real People Confessing to Javier Bardem’s To the Wonder Priest
Assembled from cut footage, the film features real-life Oklahoma residents confessing to Javier Bardem’s To the Wonder priest character.Vanderpump Rules Recap: Old Man Jax
Is Jax in the middle of a mid-life crisis?The Alienist Recap: Back to the Drawing Board
Kreizler doesn’t know nearly as much as he thinks he does.My Week With Marilyn Producer Alleges Harvey Weinstein Physically Assaulted Him
David Parfitt claims the former studio head allegedly “pinned him against a Coke machine” and threatened him over a screening of the 2011 drama.Ridley Scott Says Young Directors Have ‘No Excuses’ For Not Making Movies
The filmmaker spoke at a BAFTA retrospective of his career over the weekend.Jordan Peele Will Start Filming His Next Genre-Bending Movie Later This Year
“I’m just trying to entertain myself again.”Fergie Says She ‘Tried Her Best’ With That Risk-Taking National Anthem
“This rendition didn’t strike the intended tone.”Christopher Nolan Suavely Rules Himself Out of Directing James Bond 25
Give this man a well-shaken martini.Roseanne Barr, Patron Saint of Questionable National Anthems, Also Thought Fergie’s Rendition Was Bad
“I think mine was better.”Olympic Figure Skater Brushes Off ‘Nightmare’ Wardrobe Malfunction
Gabriella Papadakis remained cool, calm, and collected.
Neat.Adam Rippon Won’t Be Working As an NBC Olympic Correspondent After All
He’d have to give up his competitor credentials and move out of the Olympic Village, and who wants that?The Real Housewives of Atlanta Recap: Wisdom of the Elders
Is the biggest drama this season really between two people on different continents?Homeland Recap: The Lunatic Fringe
Don’t mess with Carrie Mathison.Theater Review: Is God Is Seeks the Divine
Aleasha Harris’s play is a rich gold mine. The production unearths only some of its riches.Can You Suppress Your Reaction to Fergie’s NBA All-Star National Anthem?
Draymond Green sure couldn’t.Can You Revise a Book to Make It More Woke?
When a YA novel was criticized for racism prior to publication, the author attempted something radical — she pushed its release date and rewrote it.Three Billboards Wins 5 Prizes at the 2018 BAFTA Awards
Gary Oldman, Allison Janney, and Daniel Kaluuya were among the night’s other winners.Black Panther Bounds Past Box Office Predictions for a Massive Opening Weekend
Marvel’s latest blew Deadpool away and keeps climbing over the three-day weekend.Kris Jenner Would Apparently Complain to E! About The Soup’s Kardashian Jokes Back in the Day
And, per Joel McHale, E! ultimately banned the show from Kardashian talk.