What was missing from last evening’s Wilco show at McCarren Pool? It’s difficult to be exact, with so much that seemed right: cool breezes, cold beer, greasy pork sandwiches (served by Fette Sau, and not in dirty ashtrays). Plus: the big hits, multiple encores, a high ratio of tune to noise. Perhaps it was the proverbial cock tease — not wanky enough. Let us, first, lay to rest the lazy idea that McCarren Park Pool is some hipster refuge. Yesterday, if anything (and this is taking into consideration the hipster lovelies occasionally seen cantering, foal-like, to join friends in beer lines, or perhaps simply share sweet nothings), the venue harbored middle-stream preps, members, one gathers, of New York City’s more productive industries, glad to stop off at home on the way from work to, sartorially speaking, revert — also attitudinally, perhaps — to their college days. This is all to say that the band had a golden moment: casual rock fans, but serious about a favorite group, looking for a chill time. And it was chill. But it was not bluegrass-in-a-big-field chill. Maybe it was the concrete. Maybe it was the concision of the band’s discordant eruptions. Maybe it was us, all of us — middlestream and hip of center — not quite dissolving into the moment. It was a fine time. But not quite beautiful. —Nick Catucci
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
What You Need to Know Before Seeing Star Wars: The Last Jedi
The Highs and Lows of A Christmas Story Live!
How The Last Jedi Handles Carrie Fisher’s Death
Let’s Talk About the Ending of Star Wars: The Last Jedi
Minnie Driver: If Men Like Matt Damon Have Questionable Thoughts About Sexual Misconduct, Then ‘We’re in a Lot of F-cking Trouble’
The 10 Horniest Things in Star Wars: The Last Jedi
How A Christmas Story: Live Tackled That Chinese Restaurant Scene
11,000 People Have Demanded the Met Remove This Painting. They Aren’t Going To. Nor Should They.
Mark Hamill Gets Into It With Ted Cruz Over Net Neutrality
There’s No Love Lost Between SNL’s Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner
Latest News from VultureDiddy Wants to be the New Owner of the Carolina Panthers
He threw his hat into the ring after current owner Jerry Richardson announced plans to sell the team following allegations of workplace misconduct.The Highs and Lows of A Christmas Story Live!
The good, the bad, and the leg lamp of Fox’s live musical.Here Are Our Best Guesses About the Search Party Season-Two Finale
Whodunit?A Prairie Home Companion Has a New Name Following Garrison Keillor’s Removal
Minnesota Public Radio and American Public Media planned the change after severing ties with the former radio host last month.How A Christmas Story: Live Tackled That Chinese Restaurant Scene
The carolers sing “Deck the Halls” flawlessly.Two Critics Review One Show: Farinelli and the King
A musical play about opera, reviewed by our theater and classical-music critics.Mark Hamill Gets Into It With Ted Cruz Over Net Neutrality
The Twitter beef you didn’t know you wanted, and still don’t.The Real Housewives of Atlanta Recap: The Dating Game
Shereé is living my Goodfellas dream relationship.Brit Marling Says the Second Season of Netflix’s The OA Starts Filming in January
[Excited interpretive-spider-hand-dance movement.]Wormwood Recap: The Gravedigger
The Frank Olson investigation hits a macabre and deeply moving turn of events.
It obviously made a lot of money. But how much?NBC Reportedly Paid Off Former Producer Who Accused Chris Matthews of Sexual Harassment
The producer complained to CNBC that the Hardball host had made inappropriate sexual comments about her in front of others.Rose McGowan Singles Out the ‘Hypocrisy’ of Meryl Streep and Other Actresses Planning Golden Globes Protest
“YOUR SILENCE is THE problem.”Minnie Driver: If Men Like Matt Damon Have Questionable Thoughts About Sexual Misconduct, Then ‘We’re in a Lot of F-cking Trouble’
“You can’t tell a woman about their abuse. A man cannot do that.”Saturday Night Live Recap: Kevin Hart Fights a Llama for Christmas
SNL is a great match for Kevin Hart’s enthusiastic comedy.There’s No Love Lost Between SNL’s Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner
“I’ll always remember the one time I heard him talk.”Allow SNL’s Omarosa to Gaslight You One Last Time About How She Definitely, Unquestionably, Positively, Wasn’t Fired From the White House
“I escorted myself off the premises.”Frankly, Harrison Ford Was ‘F-cking’ Upset That Mark Hamill Didn’t Share Star Wars Spoilers
“Oh my gosh, Dad Vader!”Ed Sheeran to the James Bond Franchise: Please! Use This Theme Song I Wrote!
He’s had the song on tap for three (!) years.Matt Damon Receives the Eloquent Wrath of Alyssa Milano Over His Sexual-Misconduct Opinions
“We are not outraged because someone grabbed our asses in a picture. We are outraged because we were made to feel this was normal.”