Gosh, can you believe Taylor Swift won four Grammys last night? You can? Perhaps that’s because she’s won every other award for which she’s been vaguely eligible — ACMAs, AMAs, BMAs, BMIAs, CMAAs, CMTAs, and, of course, VMAs. But if there’s one thing she’s better at than winning awards, it’s acting surprised while winning them. Last night she added an armful of Grammys, including Album of the Year, to her treasure chest, and a few more looks to her arsenal of shocked awards-show faces. Enjoy our slideshow of some of Swift’s most astonished trophy-winning expressions, captioned with actual quotes from her breathless acceptance speeches.