Roughly a month after ex-keyboardist Franz Nicolay criticized the Hold Steady for having “one big idea — making literate, wordy lyrics over big anthemic rock,” the band announced their new album, Heaven Is Whenever, and described it as “less anthemic and more complex.” Coincidence? Was Nicolay out of the loop? Or was the new sound — explained by guitarist Tad Kubler as “sonically diverse,” “dynamically expansive,” and heavily influenced by the film scores of Gustavo Santaolalla, Terence Blanchard, and Jon Brion — not enough of a departure for Franz? We won’t know until the album comes out May 4, but for now we’re wondering didn’t the band talk up a bold new direction on Stay Positive, too? (We remember Craig Finn specifically talking about getting singing lessons). And didn’t that album’s best moments (mostly “Constructive Summer”) sound like old Hold Steady? Look, we’re glad the band’s concerned with moving forward, but personally, we were hoping for a more retrograde feel (we like when Finn talk-sings) and thought we might get one, since Heaven’s producer Dean Baltulonis worked on the band’s first two albums as well. Anyway, if you’d like to take this premature analysis of an unheard album further out on your own, here’s Heaven’s just unveiled cover art.
Most Viewed Stories
Finally, a Movie About How Amy Adams and Isla Fisher Are the Exact Same Person
Watch All of the Trailers Released at San Diego Comic-Con
Ian McShane Has No Regrets About Spoiling Game of Thrones
Last Week Tonight: Usher, Sheryl Crow, Cyndi Lauper and Others Sing ‘Don’t Use Our Song’
On the Set of Jill Soloway’s Next Show, I Love Dick
A Stranger Things Glossary: Every Major Film Reference in the Show, From A–Z
Rihanna Warns Her Audience, ‘I Don’t Want to See You Catching Any Pokémons Up in This B–’
When Did the Media Turn Against Taylor Swift?
In Praise of Barb, the Best Character on Stranger Things
All 151 Pokémon in Pokémon Go, Ranked
Latest News from VulturePaul Simon Is Ready To Ease Your Mind About Hillary Clinton at the Democratic National Convention
The Grammy-winner sang “Bridge Over Troubled Water.”Casual Recap: Drought Conditions
Valerie finally decides to put herself first.Watch Ken Jeong Learn Where Trump Cufflinks, Suits and Vodka Are Made
Hint: The items weren't made in Pennsylvania.UnREAL Recap: Mommie Dearest
There's no other way to put it: This episode is a mess.Susan Sarandon Is Having a Terrible, No Good, Very Bad Democratic National Convention
She confirmed her feelings with a tweet.The Real Housewives of Orange County Recap: The Days and Nights of Kelly Dodd
God, what a mess of a party!Today in ‘Quit Playing Our Music’ News: Donald Trump Asked to Stop Playing Air Force One Score
Guess his private jet needs its own soundtrack.The Fosters Recap: Disco Lives!
Ugh, Brandon. You may have Greg Brady's perm, but you're totally a Jan.Jack White’s Third Man Records Plans to Go Where No Record Player Has Gone Before
Music loving satellites and extraterrestrials rejoice.Hamilton's Renée Elise Goldsberry to Star in HBO's The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks
She'll be the accidental mother of modern biotechnology.
Chance, Lil Wayne, Skrillex, and more will play Chicago's U.S. Cellular Field.Vladimir Putin Is Having a Rough Day Working the Phone for Donald Trump
But Roger Ailes has his own stuff going on.Everything You Missed at the Inaugural 2016 Panorama Festival
This is what the first year of the Coachella organizers' new festival looked like.Did You Catch That Rick and Morty Easter Egg in the Justice League Trailer?
All Rick and Morty need is that portal gun.Sia Lands First No. 1 As ‘Cheap Thrills’ Unseats Drake in the Hot 100
It's the first chart-topper by a woman over 40 since Madonna's "Music."Kiersey Clemons Will Play Iris West in The Flash, Which’ll Be a Pretty Dope Dope Reunion
Back at it again with Rick Famuyiwa.Panorama’s Debut Asked a Lot of Sweaty Festivalgoers, But Offered Even More in Return
The sweltering July heat transformed even the most euphoric of live sets into a war against the weather.The Definitive Proof That Gucci Mane Is Not a Clone
This doesn't mean, of course, that we shouldn't be afraid of replacement at the hands of replicants.In Praise of Barb, the Best Character on Stranger Things
She is obviously the first person to put the words “norm” and “core” together.Alicia Silverstone, Patron Saint of Beverly Hills, Joins Pilot Based on the Life of Real Housewife Kyle Richards
It's a comedy about a single mom in the 1970s.