Roughly a month after ex-keyboardist Franz Nicolay criticized the Hold Steady for having “one big idea — making literate, wordy lyrics over big anthemic rock,” the band announced their new album, Heaven Is Whenever, and described it as “less anthemic and more complex.” Coincidence? Was Nicolay out of the loop? Or was the new sound — explained by guitarist Tad Kubler as “sonically diverse,” “dynamically expansive,” and heavily influenced by the film scores of Gustavo Santaolalla, Terence Blanchard, and Jon Brion — not enough of a departure for Franz? We won’t know until the album comes out May 4, but for now we’re wondering didn’t the band talk up a bold new direction on Stay Positive, too? (We remember Craig Finn specifically talking about getting singing lessons). And didn’t that album’s best moments (mostly “Constructive Summer”) sound like old Hold Steady? Look, we’re glad the band’s concerned with moving forward, but personally, we were hoping for a more retrograde feel (we like when Finn talk-sings) and thought we might get one, since Heaven’s producer Dean Baltulonis worked on the band’s first two albums as well. Anyway, if you’d like to take this premature analysis of an unheard album further out on your own, here’s Heaven’s just unveiled cover art.
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Shia LaBeouf Is Doing a 4-Year-Long Anti-Trump Livestream Event
Channing Tatum’s Leaked Email Is Glorious
Celebrities React to Trump’s Inauguration, and Aside From Scott Baio, They’re Mostly Upset
Let’s Talk About the Ending of Split
Kristen Stewart Looks Back on Trump's Tweets About Her Robert Pattinson Split: He Was ‘Really Obsessed With Me'
Stephen Colbert Reviews Trump's Inaugural Speech on Late Show: ‘Like Lincoln Huffing Paint Thinner’
Vulture’s Final Oscar-Nomination Predictions
The 8 Best Memes of the Obama Presidency
The Good Place Pulled Off a Forking Great Twist Ending
Jessica Williams' Wonderful Response When Asked if She Misses The Daily Show
Latest News from VultureJimmy Kimmel Pledges to Keep Taking Truth to Power By Gleefully Mocking President Trump
"I ... do solemnly swear to faithfully satirize, criticize, lampoon, and harpoon the president of the United States."T.I. Urges the Oppressed to Mount a Stronger Resistance in New Open Letter
"Everything cannot be blamed on THE SYSTEM."Jessica Williams' Wonderful Response When Asked if She Misses The Daily Show
NPR and the spa, please.The One Thing Michael Showalter Says Every Romantic Comedy Needs
It's simple, really.Stephen Colbert Reviews Trump's Inaugural Speech on Late Show: ‘Like Lincoln Huffing Paint Thinner’
President of the United States of American CarnageKristen Stewart Makes a Mysterious Splash at Sundance With Her Directorial Debut
What was it about? Well ...Witchblade Is Not Quite a Witch and Not Quite a Blade, But to Answer Your Question, It Might Be a TV Reboot
Witchblade is sort of a blade, but it is also a bracelet that is an alien.Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Recap: Devil Winds
Like all the best CXG episodes, this is a jukebox musical about human frailty.Sleepy Hollow Recap: Heads Will Roll
A humble suggestion: Sleepy Hollow should rebuild around Crane, Jenny, and Jake.Frank Ocean Thinks It Would Have Been ‘Equally Presidential’ If Obama Had Walked Out of Trump's Inaugural Address
"The majority knows man, we know you did good."
Skynet cannot be defeated.Kristen Stewart Looks Back on Trump's Tweets About Her Robert Pattinson Split: He Was ‘Really Obsessed With Me'
"I literally cannot even understand it."Shia LaBeouf, Jaden Smith, and Woke Teens – Undivided – Protest Donald Trump
"I don't have any answers."New Lost City of Z Trailer: You Know, Maybe Sometimes Man's Reach Shouldn't Exceed His Grasp
Charlie Hunnam and his mustache meet their destiny.A Dog's Purpose Writer Responds to Controversy Surrounding Alleged Animal Abuse
He says the leaked video footage "mischaracterizes what happened."Get Through the Trump Presidency With an Updating Playlist of 1,000 Days of 1,000 Protest Songs
A new song will be added each weekday for the next four years.See New Trump-Era Posters From Obama ‘Hope’ Artist Shepard Fairey
Thousands of posters were printed.What the Future of Political Podcasts Looks Like in the Trump Era
Will listeners flock to shows like Pod Save America that embrace activism?All the Latest Songs Protesting Donald Trump’s Inauguration and Raising Money for Charity
Fiona Apple, Gorillaz, Sleater-Kinney, and many more will not be silenced.Celebrities React to Trump’s Inauguration, and Aside From Scott Baio, They’re Mostly Upset
Tell us how to feel, Adele!