Roughly a month after ex-keyboardist Franz Nicolay criticized the Hold Steady for having “one big idea — making literate, wordy lyrics over big anthemic rock,” the band announced their new album, Heaven Is Whenever, and described it as “less anthemic and more complex.” Coincidence? Was Nicolay out of the loop? Or was the new sound — explained by guitarist Tad Kubler as “sonically diverse,” “dynamically expansive,” and heavily influenced by the film scores of Gustavo Santaolalla, Terence Blanchard, and Jon Brion — not enough of a departure for Franz? We won’t know until the album comes out May 4, but for now we’re wondering didn’t the band talk up a bold new direction on Stay Positive, too? (We remember Craig Finn specifically talking about getting singing lessons). And didn’t that album’s best moments (mostly “Constructive Summer”) sound like old Hold Steady? Look, we’re glad the band’s concerned with moving forward, but personally, we were hoping for a more retrograde feel (we like when Finn talk-sings) and thought we might get one, since Heaven’s producer Dean Baltulonis worked on the band’s first two albums as well. Anyway, if you’d like to take this premature analysis of an unheard album further out on your own, here’s Heaven’s just unveiled cover art.
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Our Biggest Questions After the Westworld Finale
The 10 Best TV Shows of 2016
James Marsden Is One of the Best Actors of His Generation. Why Hasn’t Hollywood Noticed?
Westworld Season-Finale Recap: This World Doesn’t Belong to You
Why Westworld Is Such an Unlikely Success Story for HBO
What’s New on Netflix: December 2016
How Crash Crashed the Oscars
Jon Stewart Has a Very Simple Solution for How to Stop Spreading Fake News
There Are Two Westworlds
Tom Ford Maintains His Position That All Men Should Get Penetrated at Least Once
Latest News from VultureTrevor Noah Compares Donald Trump's Allies to Enablers
"A drunk is a drunk, but the person who encourages him to drive? That's an asshole."Steve Harvey Hijacked the Tonight Show To Host Family Feud
Annette Bening, Greta Gerwig and Jimmy Fallon versus The Roots.Theater Review: A Long Commute on The Babylon Line
"Failure to thrive."Van Williams, Star of TV's Green Hornet, Dead at 82
He also appeared in The Beverly Hillbillies and The Dick Van Dyke Show.
"This is really a bigger job than I thought."The First Teaser for Transformers: The Last Knight Trailer Goes Boom
“You want to know, don’t you? Why they keep coming here.”Chris Rock Announces His First Major Stand-Up Tour in Nine Years: Total Blackout
"Hey, it's time."Vanderpump Rules Recap: May the Schwartz Be with You
What, exactly, is going on with Tom's bulge?Madonna Ignores Seat Belt Laws To Shake Her Booty With James Corden in Carpool Karaoke Teaser
The full segment airs Wednesday.How To Train Your Dragon 3 Won't Soar Into Theaters Until 2019
We will have to wait an extra year for more dragons.
The singer hopes the president will quash corporate interests.Bill Cosby’s Damning Testimony Will Be Allowed in His Sexual-Assault Trial
He admitted to drugging women for sex in unsealed testimony from Andrea Constand's 2005 lawsuit.Atlanta, Stranger Things, and Transparent Among the 2016 Writers Guild of America TV Nominees
Honoring the year's top television, new media, news, and radio achievements.Adult Swim Cancels the ‘Alt-Right’-Courting Comedy Show Million Dollar Extreme Presents: World Peace
After months of pushback.The Real Story of the Life Magazine ‘Camelot’ Interview in Jackie
You can read Jackie Kennedy's margin notes online.Everything You Need to Know Ahead of the 2017 Grammy Nominations
It'll be a Beyoncé-Adele showdown.The 10 Best TV Episodes of 2016
Narrative innovation was on full display this year, including in a throwback entry from a revived classic.The 10 Best TV Shows of 2016
Including a pair of O.J. stories and an online-only passion project.Tom Ford Maintains His Position That All Men Should Get Penetrated at Least Once
No, not emotionally.Alec Baldwin’s Role in the Movie Glengarry Glen Ross Was a Repaid Favor
The film's writer David Mamet reveals why he was indebted to the actor.