Roughly a month after ex-keyboardist Franz Nicolay criticized the Hold Steady for having “one big idea — making literate, wordy lyrics over big anthemic rock,” the band announced their new album, Heaven Is Whenever, and described it as “less anthemic and more complex.” Coincidence? Was Nicolay out of the loop? Or was the new sound — explained by guitarist Tad Kubler as “sonically diverse,” “dynamically expansive,” and heavily influenced by the film scores of Gustavo Santaolalla, Terence Blanchard, and Jon Brion — not enough of a departure for Franz? We won’t know until the album comes out May 4, but for now we’re wondering didn’t the band talk up a bold new direction on Stay Positive, too? (We remember Craig Finn specifically talking about getting singing lessons). And didn’t that album’s best moments (mostly “Constructive Summer”) sound like old Hold Steady? Look, we’re glad the band’s concerned with moving forward, but personally, we were hoping for a more retrograde feel (we like when Finn talk-sings) and thought we might get one, since Heaven’s producer Dean Baltulonis worked on the band’s first two albums as well. Anyway, if you’d like to take this premature analysis of an unheard album further out on your own, here’s Heaven’s just unveiled cover art.
Most Viewed Stories
Every Coen Brothers Movie, Ranked From Worst to Best
The 100 Jokes That Shaped Modern Comedy
The Rocky Horror Picture Show Cast Takes Their 40th-Anniversary Reunion Photo
Just Another Moment You Wish Judge Judy Were Your Mom
The Friday Night Lights 10-Year Reunion Is Happening in Austin Because Texas Forever
Martin Is Not Happy Kurt Russell Smashed Its Priceless Antique Guitar in Hateful Eight
Can You Tell Which Paul Rudd Is Older? (We Doubt It)
It’s Time to Start Watching Poldark
Kate del Castillo Feels ‘Betrayed’ and ‘Used’ by Sean Penn Because of His El Chapo Article
Yanic Truesdale Is a Lot More Excited to Work With Lauren Graham Again Than Michel Gerard Ever Would Be
Latest News from VultureIggy Pop Says Post Pop Depression Could Be His Last Album
The godfather of punk says his "energy's more limited now."The Choice Isn't a Good Movie, But It Has Puppies
It’s hard to resist a goddamn Nicholas Sparks movie with puppies.Beyonce Discusses Her Iconic Super Bowl Performance in a Rare Interview
"It's one of those magical performances that you can't recreate."What Happens When Bernie Sanders Gets Morphed With David Bowie: Meet 'Bernie Stardust'
#FeelTheZiggyAnthony Anderson Addresses Oscars Controversy at the NAACP Image Awards
"Hollywood needs to know that this is what diversity is supposed to look like."The Vampire Diaries Recap: Drowning Together
It will surprise no one that Elena gets hurt when Damon can’t confront his feelings. Like always.Tidal Is Donating $1.5 Million to Charities, Including Black Lives Matter
Jay Z's company raised the money at last year's Tidal X: 10/20 concert.Woody Harrelson Applied for a Pot Dispensary License in Hawaii, in a Fitting Epilogue for Every Character He's Played
True Detective season 3?John Krasinski on His Successful Sundance Doubleheader
"To have people walk out crying is the best compliment I could get."Yanic Truesdale Is a Lot More Excited to Work With Lauren Graham Again Than Michel Gerard Ever Would Be
The inn is back in business.
It's a very Posh look.Rebel Wilson and Jimmy Fallon Sing About Being Single and Then Play Chubby Bunny, As If to Confirm the First Thing
When Rebel Wilson plays, she commits.Bobby Cannavale Is Worried Martin Scorsese Spends Too Much Time With Him, in Today's Least Relatable Complaint
It's a little Larry David.Sleepy Hollow Recap: Mirror, Mirror
Conspiracy theories abound, people.Hold on to Your Fedoras: Bruno Mars Will Perform With Beyoncé and Coldplay at Super Bowl 50
Treasure! That is what you are!Jennifer Lopez Will Have to Magically Find More Time in Her Schedule for Shades of Blue Season 2
NBC is sticking with J.Lo.Martin Is Not Happy Kurt Russell Smashed Its Priceless Antique Guitar in Hateful Eight
The production was supposed to swap it out for a replica.How Comedy Finally Caught Up to Female Comedians
Things have changed since Elayne Boosler.Samuel L. Jackson, Mad Max, and Susan Sontag: My Road Trip With A.O. Scott
I arrived at his house in Prospect–Lefferts Gardens around 8:15, and we set out in his blue Subaru.Samantha Bee on Diversity: ‘The F*cking Thing You Have to Do Is Just Hire People’
“It's not really the most complicated transaction."