Has American Idol felt off its game? Is it less vibrant and buzzy than at any point in its eight-year reign? (Remember, a few weeks ago Dancing With the Stars even beat it in the ratings.) Have you not been recently peer-pressured into watching one of the previous night's performances the morning after? The Wrap smartly suggests that we don't blame Ryan's attitude problem or the fact that Ellen's not Paula for this turn of events. Instead, we should blame Glee for showing Idol up on a weekly basis. "Next to Glee's supercharged vocals, over-the-top choreography and radiant glow of professionalism — not to mention white-hot record sales of late — those kids struggling away on Idol are starting to look kinda ... lame," writes Josh Dickey. Of course, Idol still gets much higher ratings than Glee, but it no longer feels like the water-cooler musical program of the moment. If Glee continues to dominate, even after Idol winnows down to its final few, it will only have taken professionally trained singers, dancers, and writers nine seasons to exact their revenge. [Wrap]
Most Viewed Stories
A Film Producer Is Tweeting Out Terrible Descriptions of Female Characters in Scripts
It Has Been a Very Long Time Since a Monologue Joke Bombed As Hard As the One Seth Meyers Tried Last Night
Real Housewives of Beverly Hills Recap: Whatever Happened to Erika Jayne?
Deadpool and the Promising Rise of Heteroflexibility in Comedies
How the Video of Christine Chubbuck’s Suicide Became a Very Macabre ‘Holy Grail’
The 100 Jokes That Shaped Modern Comedy
Sutton Foster Joins the Gilmore Girls Revival, Because Netflix Has Apparently Decided to Bring Back Bunheads Too
What It’s Like to Win an Oscar
Liz Meriwether on How They Changed New Girl While Zooey Deschanel Is on Maternity Leave
Jared Padalecki’s Dean to Return for Gilmore Girls Revival; Christopher and Doyle Are Back, Too!
Latest News from VultureThe Trailer for Garry Marshall’s Mother’s Day Is Here, and It Has So Many Celebrities, Your Brain Will Explode!
Will Garry run out of holidays?Theater Review: Encores! Tries to Renovate Cabin in the Sky
Rehabbing a musical that'd be unproducible today.Jared Padalecki’s Dean to Return for Gilmore Girls Revival; Christopher and Doyle Are Back, Too!
It's all happening.Batman v Superman Final Trailer: Let’s Get to the Good Stuff, Shall We?
It's intense.Pretty Little Liars’ Janel Parrish on the Mona vs. Spencer Rivalry
The show's resident troublemaker on her much-awaited return.American Crime Recap: Confronting Things
Until its intense final few minutes, this was the show's most frustrating episode.Marie Kondo Filming Two-Part KonMari Method Special in NYC, After Which We Will All Finally Be Happy and in Control of Our Sloppy Lives
America's socks have never been happier.Equals Trailer: Humanity’s Future Depends on Kristen Stewart and Nicholas Hoult’s Shameless Flirting
How sexually tense are you right now?OK Go’s New Zero Gravity ‘Upside Down & Inside Out’ Video Is Astronomically Charming
Oh man! These guys.The Walking Dead’s Sarah Wayne Callies Saved Carol From Becoming Zombie Meat
We all need guardian angels.
Furthering your Netflix addiction.Outlander Season Two Trailer: For the Television Viewer Who Wants Everything They Love on One Show
"Change the future? Is such a thing possible?"The Toughest Song I Wrote: Courtney Barnett on Taking 5 Years to Write a Set of Lyrics
"Part of it reminded me of Lou Reed."Bruce Springsteen to Write Autobiography, Born to Run, Though All of His Song Titles Would Work, Which Is Very Satisfying
See the cover!Meryl Streep Said ‘We’re All Africans, Really’ in Response to Diversity Questions at the Berlin Film Festival
"This jury is evidence that at least women are included."Stephen Colbert Went on a Glorious Pun Run, Courtesy of Bernie Sandwiches
This is making us very hungry.Michael Mann Looks Back on His Career, Talks Innovation, Dialogue, and Diversity
“I do some of my best work when I’m on a personal frontier, pushing different ways of conveying an emotion.”See DC’s New Line of Harley Quinn Action Figures
Designed by superstar comics artist Amanda Conner.The Deadpool Moment: The Secret History of Marvel’s Boom Brand
He went from comic-book zero to cinema hero.What It’s Like to Win an Oscar
Eight winners reflect on the humdrum and the surreal.