Vulture

Skip to content, or skip to search.

who did it best

Glee vs. YouTube: Who Did ‘Umbrella’ Best?

On last night's Glee, Mr. Schue got over the monkey flu just in time to save himself from being fired and take his job back from Holly Holiday, Gwyneth Paltrow's unsettlingly cool substitute teacher. Oh, and also to create a mash-up of his favorite musical, Singin' in the Rain, and Rihanna's "Umbrella," for which he, Gwynnie, and the kids flooded the auditorium stage and splashed around in galoshes — fun! But was it as fun as the Baseballs' version? What about the Duke's Men of Yale? They seem to be having a pretty good time.

Compare these versions of Rihanna's "Umbrella" and tell us: Who did it best?

As Performed By

The Baseballs

What tall pompadours you have.

As Performed By

Julien Doré and Coeur de Pirate

We checked: "Pirate" means the same thing in French as it does in English.

As Performed By

The Duke's Men of Yale

They may be singing Rihanna, but their hips don't lie.

As Performed By

Vanilla Sky

Is this video actually confusing, or do we just not get it?

As Performed By

Mandy Moore

This would have worked just as well as "Only Hope" in A Walk to Remember.

As Performed By

Glee

With Gwyneth Paltrow!