Skip to content, or skip to search.


Which Critical Darlings Mystified You the Most?

Looking at all the best-of lists, critics' picks, and year-end accolades, which roundly praised and rewarded movie, TV, album, or book has you scratching your head in disbelief or fuming in disagreement? And which of your favorites are getting unjustly overlooked?

Photo: Alex John Beck (Vampire Weekend), Fox (Lone Star), Warner Bros. (Inception, spinning top), AMC (Mad Men), The Weinsten Company (King’s Speech), Courtesy of Farrar, Straus and Giroux (Franzen), Frank Micelotta/Getty Images for VH1 (Kanye)