Since the documentary Catfish debuted at Sundance in January, questions have been raised about the film's veracity. Though co-directors Ariel Schulman and Henry Joost have maintained that Catfish is a non-staged work of complete nonfiction, a new lawsuit contesting the fair use of a song by the singer Amy Kuney in the film is calling the true nature of the project in question. (Spoilers ahead!) In Catfish, Kuney's music was used by a middle-aged Michigan woman — who invents an entire network of imaginary people on Facebook (including a daughter, who she falsely claimed wrote the track) — in order to befriend Schulman's brother Nev. Catfish producers claimed the song is covered under fair use, since the movie is a documentary. But Kuney's label, Threshold Records, is hoping to collect license fees by getting them to admit that some scenes were staged. If Kuney and Threshold are correct, it would be sort of ironic if it were the same song that helped unravel the hoax in the film as well as the film itself.
Most Viewed Stories
Sam Smith Has to Pay Royalties to Tom Petty for ‘Stay With Me’
Why Larry David the Schmuck Was the Best Thing to Happen to Larry David the Mensch
9 Things Lena Dunham, Mindy Kaling, and Your Other Female Faves Said at Sundance
SAG Awards 2015: The Complete Winners List
Look at Nick Offerman’s New, Mustache-less Face
Emma Stone Tripped Naomi Watts, Reacted Delightfully
Emile Hirsch Might Have Assaulted a Film Executive
Here’s a Photo of Tom Hanks Taking Up Two Subway Seats
Last Night’s Girls Had the Quintessential Hannah Moment
Andrew Rannells on Girls and His Love for Lena Dunham and Nancy Meyers
Latest News on VultureDavid Tennant to Play Villain in Netflix’s Jessica Jones
He will literally be a purple man.Former Film Executive Says Bill Cosby Drugged and Raped Her in 1969
She says Cosby gave her a mysterious pill to cure her headache.If You Want Joss Whedon to Direct More Avengers Movies, Better Start Begging Now
"It's enormously hard."Bob’s Burgers Recap: Rolling in the Arugula
Get ready for vegetable puns.Everything That’s Happened Around Adnan Syed’s Case Since ‘Serial’ Premiered: A Timeline
Finally, a "Serial" timeline that does not include cell-phone records or Leakin Park.American Idol Winner Phillip Phillips Wants Out of His ‘Oppressive’ Contract
He has lodged a petition with the California Labor Commissioner.Beauty and the Beast Should Be All Harry Potter People
Sort of the characters, sort of the actors.Patton Oswalt on Selma’s Oscar Snub and the Racist Backlash to the New Star Wars Trailer
"Is just logic. It goes beyond race."Remember When Tom Petty Didn’t Mind Being Unintentionally Plagiarized?
That ship has sailed, Sam Smith.Selma’s Ava DuVernay to Make a Katrina-Set Murder-Mystery Movie
And David Oyelowo is in negotiations to produce and star.
Finally, a chance to see comic books brought to life!Michael Keaton Is Into Your Crush on His Hot Son
"He's a handsome dude."Emma Stone Tripped Naomi Watts, Reacted Delightfully
There's a Vine!The Story Behind Sundance Smash Me and Earl and the Dying Girl
The film is closing in on a record-breaking $12 million sale price.Read an Annotated Excerpt From Adam Sternbergh’s Near Enemy
The New York editor's new novel is out now.Emma Watson Will Play Belle in Live-Action Beauty and the Beast
Weird, right?Last Night’s Girls Had the Quintessential Hannah Moment
She's right about her classmates. But she's wrong about saying it.Harvey Weinstein: Everything Bad You’ve Heard About Me Is a Lie
He swears he never ran a negative campaign in his life.Real Housewives of Atlanta Recap: The Mandingo and the Masturbatorium
Sports bars ≠ ballers, Cynthia.Sam Smith Has to Pay Royalties to Tom Petty for ‘Stay With Me’
You were right: "Stay With Me" is totally like "I Won't Back Down."
"Nancy [Meyers] to me is the ultimate, and it did not disappoint. It’s like 50 Shades of Cream on that set."Brooklyn Nine-Nine Recap: The Chamber of Asses
Gina gets a serious moment, and Amy meets the comptroller.Look at Nick Offerman’s New, Mustache-less Face
It is like the Mona Lisa, but with a chin strap, basically.Emile Hirsch Might Have Assaulted a Film Executive
Who works at Paramount Pictures.SAG Awards 2015: The Complete Winners List
Viola Davis and Uzo Aduba made SAG history.Full House Cast Reunites, Sings the Show’s Theme Song
For series creator Jeff Franklin’s birthday.Adam Scott and Jason Schwartzman on Their Sundance Comedy The Overnight and Prosthetic Penises
"Aside from that thing there, you are totally nude. And it's pretty scary, but it's liberating, too."
It airs on HBO in March.Theater Review: Trying to Smarten Up Vampire Romance, With Let the Right One In
"Let’s face it: Vampire stories are not the deep end of literature, no matter what metaphorical pretensions are offered in their defense."Looking Recap: A New Leaf
This week welcomed back the show's distinctive, subtle groove.
Everyone's making the wrong connections.Downton Abbey Recap: Shooting Up, Mouthing Off
Things get a little more interesting at Downton. Oh, and a lot more heroin-y.Girls Recap: A Very Culturally Specific Statement
Everyone is unraveling.Why Larry David the Schmuck Was the Best Thing to Happen to Larry David the Mensch
Everyone’s favorite curmudgeon is bringing his particular brand of disagreeability to Broadway. In a play about the ultimate nothing.9 Things Lena Dunham, Mindy Kaling, and Your Other Female Faves Said at Sundance
Movie studios still don't know what to do with female writers.Sons of Liberty Is Pretty Good, in Between the Action Scenes
It gets better as it goes along, but you should still probably just re-watch John Adams.American Sniper Has Brought in More Than $200 Million at the Box Office
Welcome to America.Sundance: Twisty-Turny Punk-Comedy-Thriller Dope Stands Out
There's a good reason that Rick Famuyiwa's film has hit the festival like a neutron bomb.Sundance: Chris Pine and Zachary Quinto on Their Best Friendship
And how Pine would die in the apocalypse.Saturday Night Live: Blake Shelton Stars in The Voice Crossover Episode
It's synergy, baby!
The race is on.Rihanna, Kanye, and Paul McCartney Release New Collaboration
It's called "FourFiveSeconds."Sundance: Diary of a Teenage Girl Steers Clear of Scolding or Moralizing
And young star Bel Powley is staggeringly good in it.Sundance: Tense, Frightening The Witch Places Viewers in the Minds of Puritan Settlers
A place of terrors both imagined and real.Sundance: Z for Zachariah Doesn’t Live Up to Expectations
The descent into a tepid thriller of sexual jealousy slowly negates the film's abstract, almost metaphorical quality.
#manspreading?Stephen Collins’s Divorce Is (Finally) Finalized
Bye.Did We Turn George R.R. Martin On to Free the Nipple?
Maybe.Watch Gwyneth Paltrow and Johnny Depp Play Never Have I Ever
Who's part of the mile-high club?Sundance: You’ll Never Guess Who Jack Black Just Hooked Up With
It's a shocker.