In the pursuit of some higher objectivity, let's declare a bias: This particular blogger wishes nothing for Britney Spears so much as a truly excellent single, if not one quite on the majestic order of "Toxic" — because, real talk, what's on the order of "Toxic"? It's too high a bar — at least a song that throws some elbows at "Hit Me Baby," "Oops," and "Stronger" in an attempt to make room for itself in the Spears canon. Alas, Spears's new single "Hold It Against Me" does not belong in such vaunted company. This despite the fact that it has been produced by Dr. Luke and Max Martin, has an undercover killer of a chorus that plays like the sweetie pie "Sometimes" got remixed as a dance track, and also contains a doozy of a double entendre. (Chorus: “If I said my heart was beating loud / If we could escape the crowd somehow / If I said I want your body now / Would you hold it against me?" Um, excuse me, hold what against you exactly?) What's bringing this song down — and, fair warning, it's not bringing it down far enough to keep it from getting stuck in your head — is a mess of a spoken-word bridge that sounds like dozens of effects, including Spears's voice, have been thrown into the Cuisinart, and similarly overstuffed verses that don't play nearly as power-pop clean as the far superior chorus. While this song is fun enough to dance to at a club and rock out to in a car, Spears isn't really going to be in top form until she can prevail on Dr. Luke and Max Martin to sell her the higher-quality stuff they're currently dealing to Katy and Avril.
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
33 New (and 16 Returning) Shows to Watch This Fall
Better Call Saul Recap: Bayou Bayou, Baby
Pete Davidson, a Romantic, Says He Was ‘Jerking Off to’ Ariana Grande Before He Met Her
The Real Housewives of Orange County Recap: Italian Scallions
Listen to Lady Gaga’s A Star Is Born Ballad ‘Is That Alright?’
Oscar Futures: A Best Picture Contender Is Born?
Every Will Smith Movie Performance, Ranked
Kate McKinnon the Latest Blonde to Join Roger Ailes Fox News Sexual-Harassment Movie
South Park Returns to Comedy Central This Week With a School-Shooting Episode
A Premature Attempt at the 21st Century Canon
Latest News from VultureEx-Southern Charm Star Thomas Ravenel Arrested for Assault and Battery
Bravo confirmed that he’s off the reality show.Everything We Know About the Veronica Mars Revival
And why the Veronica Mars book series may play a major role.9 Episodes That’ll Make You Love The Big Bang Theory
A beginner’s guide to the long-running sitcom.Bill Cosby Sentenced to 3 to 10 years in State Prison for 2004 Sexual Assault
He is now officially classified a “sexually violent predator.”Veronica Mars Writers Room Adds Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, Of Course
A renaissance man!Andrew Lloyd Webber Hasn’t Met Taylor Swift, But He Likes That She’s a Cat Person
He hints at who she’ll be playing in the Cats movie.How BTS’s Embrace of Korean Tradition Helped Them Blow Up
It’s a statement of confidence in their identity.Which Tea With the Dames Dame Are You?
Are you petty like Maggie Smith or an HBIC like Judi Dench?Natasha Rothwell Says Saturday Night Live Is ‘Hyperaware’ of Diversity Problem
“The true evidence of diversity on that show will be longevity.”Read the Powerful Statements from Andrea Constand, Janie Dickinson, and More Cosby Accusers
“Bill Cosby took my beautiful, healthy young spirit and crushed it.”
“I didn’t report it. Not to my mother, not to my friends and certainly not to the police.”How BoJack Horseman Addresses the Silencing of Women
In BoJack’s very meta fifth season, women are ignored and assert themselves in spite of it.Adam Resnick Breaks Down the Surreal W.C. Fields Comedy Million Dollar Legs
“It was so strange, it actually creeped me out a little. Which is my sweet spot, I guess.”Fyre Festival Founder Says Mental Illness Led Him to Commit Fraud
He has “delusional beliefs” according to a psych report.Opera Review: The Met Brings Back Samson et Dalila, With Just Enough Fromage
“To describe it as gaudy and silly is a compliment, not a complaint.”What’s the Right Will Smith Movie for You? Here’s a Streaming Guide to All 27
Sorting out the movie star’s highs and lows.Making a Murderer Is Coming Back Very Soon, Specifically on October 19
The season will take a look at the post-conviction process.It’s All Happening (in Song): Cameron Crowe Is Turning Almost Famous Into Musical
Next to Normal’s Tom Kitt will write the music.Okay, But Really, Who Is the More Genuinely Upsetting Joker: Joaquin Phoenix or Tommy Wiseau?
What if they made a Joker movie that had, like, double Jokers?Behind the Scenes of The Bachelor: Vietnam’s Surprise Love Story
“It was this gigantic declaration that no one saw coming,” says the show’s executive producer.