Tonight CBS airs week three of Paula Abdul's Live to Dance, and the semifinals continue, with Paula and two less-famous friends kindly judging the skills and dreams of aspiring hoofers. Even as the field narrows, the format remains emphatically friendly: Auditioners are awarded Gold Stars (great!) or Red Stars (still great, just less great), and even the first-round dismissals — which on her alma mater, American Idol, were an opportunity for dismissive mockery — came with a Paula pep talk and grateful applause. The show is a sunny, Xanax-powered alternate universe where life carries on as if Simon Cowell's eyes had never rolled. But the problem is, everyone is so nice that it's confusing! In a no-negativity zone, how are the contestants supposed to gauge Paula's real feelings, and therefore their odds of winning? To help these living-to-dance aspirants, Vulture has prepared a guide to Paula's many on-air faces (culled from her current show and Idol): They're the only clues to her true emotions — and the only way to predict her decision. Gold Star or Red Star? The answers await.BEGIN SLIDESHOW
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
SNL Says Goodbye to Barack Obama With Poignant 'To Sir, With Love' Performance
At the Sundance Women's March, Jessica Williams Excels in the Role of Inspirational Leader
Saturday Night Live Recap: Aziz Ansari Cheers Up a Trumped Nation
Everything's Coming Up Kellyanne Conway in SNL Musical Number
Aziz Ansari Tells Trump's White Supremacists to Go Back to Where They Came From (a Time When They Had to Pretend Not to Be Racist) on SNL
Shia LaBeouf Is Doing a 4-Year-Long Anti-Trump Livestream Event
La La Land’s Ending Reveals the Movie’s True Romance
Paul Scheer Nails Why Being a New Parent Ruins Your Best Friendships
Let’s Talk About the Ending of Split
Scarlett Johansson at Women's March on Washington: 'Don't Let the Feelings of Helplessness Make You Complacent'
Latest News from VultureMadonna Clarifies That Her 'Blowing Up the White House' Comment Does Not in Fact Mean She Intends to Blow the White House Up
She says it was "one phrase taken wildly out of context."Sundance: Anton Yelchin Is as Good as He's Ever Been In One of His Final Film Roles
Few actors are better than Yelchin at being both blustering and vulnerable.Bruce Springsteen on Women's March: 'We Are the New American Resistance'
Springsteen couldn't be with the protesters in body, but boy is he there in spirit.Director David Ayer on Suicide Squad: I 'Wish I Had a Time Machine'
His solution somehow involves more Joker.Sundance: The Discovery Is Netflix's Spritual Cousin to The OA
The sci-fi film looks primed to benefit from Netflix's hit show about the afterlife.New King Arthur: Legend Of The Sword Trailer for You, From Guy Ritchie
Charlie Hunnam is an old-time guy.Amazon Spends $12 Million on Sundance Rom-Com The Big Sick from Kumail Nanjiani, Michael Showalter, and Judd Apatow
One of the first big buys of this year's festival.Kristen Stewart Is Making a 'Kick Ass' Short Film About Gun Control
"My next short is so political."Taylor Swift, Zendaya, Jessica Chastain, and More Among Celebs Showing Support for Women's March
Taylor Swift, Jessica Chastain, and Zendaya are among the supporters.Cher on Trump Supporters: 'We Are Going to Kick Their Ass'
"His supporters always call us whiners, but we are going to kick their ass."
On February 4.Saturday Night Live Recap: Aziz Ansari Cheers Up a Trumped Nation
Aziz Ansari brings a joyful, exuberant presence to Studio 8H.SNL Says Goodbye to Barack Obama With Poignant 'To Sir, With Love' Performance
Hold yourself together.Everything's Coming Up Kellyanne Conway in SNL Musical Number
"And when the world goes up in flames, at least I'll know they knew my name."Aziz Ansari Tells Trump's White Supremacists to Go Back to Where They Came From (a Time When They Had to Pretend Not to Be Racist) on SNL
"You gotta go back to pretending."At the Sundance Women's March, Jessica Williams Excels in the Role of Inspirational Leader
"I am my ancestors' dream," she told the crowd.Paul Scheer Nails Why Being a New Parent Ruins Your Best Friendships
"You're just awash with people you wouldn't even want to have dinner with."Is This the Most Politically Relevant Film at Sundance?
A uniquely relevant movie for our time.The Cast of The Little Hours Sets the Bar High for Awkward Crotch Sniffing
A new low or a new high?We Asked Rashida Jones About Her First Concert Which She Described As "Magic"
The King of Pop delivered.