Last June, rumors emerged that Joseph Gordon-Levitt was “in talks” to star as the Riddler in Christopher Nolan’s third Batman movie. Then last night, presumably by sheer coincidence, Mike Fleming reported that Gordon-Levitt really is in talks to join The Dark Knight Rises (though no word on which role he’s negotiating for). So as long as Nolan is inadvertently making blog posts come true, which other completely made-up Batman casting rumor from the past couple of years would you like to see become reality? Phillip Seymour Hoffman as the Penguin? Johnny Depp as the Riddler? Shia LaBeouf as Robin? Let us know!