In her review of HBO's Game of Thrones in the New York Times today, Ginia Bellafante argues that the series appeals to men: "While I do not doubt that there are women in the world who read books like Mr. Martin’s, I can honestly say that I have never met a single woman who has stood up in indignation at her book club and refused to read the latest from Lorrie Moore unless everyone agreed to The Hobbit first. Game of Thrones is boy fiction patronizingly turned out to reach the population’s other half." Needless to say, the characterization of the series as "boy fiction" has some women up in arms ("NYT disses thousands of intelligent female viewers who may or may not already like #GameofThrones," goes one tweet, and there are plenty more like it. Io9 has a funny this review is bogus, but Game probably does appeal to boys piece as well). Is Bellafante's observation baloney? Isn't it fair to say that these books, even though they appeal to some women, may be more popular with men, like most fantasy series? Or does that diminish the books, and both genders, in some way? And is describing something as "boy fiction" or "girl fiction" a helpful distinction, or just unnecessarily reductive?
Most Viewed Stories
Real Housewives of Beverly Hills Recap: Whatever Happened to Erika Jayne?
It Has Been a Very Long Time Since a Monologue Joke Bombed As Hard As the One Seth Meyers Tried Last Night
Stephen King Confirms Idris Elba and Matthew McConaughey Are in Talks for That Dark Tower Adaptation
Liz Meriwether on How They Changed New Girl While Zooey Deschanel Is on Maternity Leave
Archie Comic Reveals Jughead Is Asexual
The 100 Jokes That Shaped Modern Comedy
David Schwimmer on Why He Wanted to Play Robert Kardashian in The People v. O.J. Simpson
The Rocky Horror Picture Show Cast Takes Their 40th-Anniversary Reunion Photo
Kanye West Says Bill Cosby Is Innocent
The Complete Guide to Beyoncé’s ‘Formation’
Latest News from VultureJohnny Depp Stars in Funny or Die’s Donald Trump Biopic, Tragically Too Late for Oscar Season
Money! Power! Sex! Brass!If You Laugh at Larry Wilmore’s ‘People v. Bill Cosby’ Skit, You Must Acquit
Don't drink the shake!Courteney Cox Is Your Latest Friend Headed Back to TV
What was in the water at that "reunion"?Aaron Sorkin Adapting To Kill a Mockingbird for Broadway, Which Is Really Quite Something
To be directed by The King and I's Bartlett Sher.Lana Del Rey’s Freaky ‘Freak’ Music Video Will Make You Want to Swim, Do Drugs, and Buy Hair Product
With Father John Misty!Ghostface Killah Finally Responded to Martin Shkreli’s Video Threat With a Video of His Own
R.I.P., Shkreli.Limitless Recap: A Bazillion Creepy Robots
Who else wants to know more about the guy dating a robot in his basement?iZombie Recap: Who’s the Boss?
It might be time to start caring about Stacey Boss.Pretty Little Liars Recap: Hiding in Plain Sight
Why is Ali cowering in front of Sad Robyn?A Deadpool Sequel Has Already Been Approved
The first film's writers are working on the follow-up script.
You heard it here first: Financial competency is sexy.
How a playwright becomes a playwright, in a play.Real Housewives of Beverly Hills Recap: Whatever Happened to Erika Jayne?
There are so many levels of miscommunication going on here!Behind The People v. O.J. Simpson’s Bronco-Car-Chase Episode
The familiar scene caused four accidents on the 710.David Schwimmer on Why He Wanted to Play Robert Kardashian in The People v. O.J. Simpson
"Robert is the only person who has nothing to gain."The People v. O.J. Simpson Recap: The Bronco Chase
The seeds of a "not guilty" verdict were planted on June 17, 1994.Classic Cool Guy Johnny Depp Will Star As Invisible Guy in Cool Reboot of the Classic Invisible Man Story
For Universal.Brooklyn Nine-Nine Recap: The Thoroughly Messed-Up Millies
Nothing is more important to Boyle than being besties with Jake.Agent Carter Recap: How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb
In theory, this is Peggy's more important mission. So why does it feel so goofy?The Muppets Recap: Unveil the Tail
I think … I actually liked this episode?