In her review of HBO's Game of Thrones in the New York Times today, Ginia Bellafante argues that the series appeals to men: "While I do not doubt that there are women in the world who read books like Mr. Martin’s, I can honestly say that I have never met a single woman who has stood up in indignation at her book club and refused to read the latest from Lorrie Moore unless everyone agreed to The Hobbit first. Game of Thrones is boy fiction patronizingly turned out to reach the population’s other half." Needless to say, the characterization of the series as "boy fiction" has some women up in arms ("NYT disses thousands of intelligent female viewers who may or may not already like #GameofThrones," goes one tweet, and there are plenty more like it. Io9 has a funny this review is bogus, but Game probably does appeal to boys piece as well). Is Bellafante's observation baloney? Isn't it fair to say that these books, even though they appeal to some women, may be more popular with men, like most fantasy series? Or does that diminish the books, and both genders, in some way? And is describing something as "boy fiction" or "girl fiction" a helpful distinction, or just unnecessarily reductive?
Most Viewed Stories
Rihanna Broke Drake’s Heart at the VMAs
Watch Rihanna’s Career-Spanning Performances at the 2016 VMAs
Drake Posts Instagram to Prove He Really Is Dating Rihanna and Isn’t Just a Weird Stalker
Let’s Discuss The Night Of Finale, ‘Call of the Wild’
The Highs and Lows of the 2016 MTV Video Music Awards
Flea Responds to Fox News’ Red Hot Chili Peppers Attacks: ‘They’re All Welcome to Hate Us’
Gene Wilder, the Original Willy Wonka, Dead at 83
See All the MTV VMA 2016 Red-Carpet Looks
The Night Of Finale Recap: Beyond a Reasonable Doubt
The Night Of Didn’t Live Up to Its Best Moments
Latest News from VultureMatt Bomer to Star as a Transgender Woman Opposite John Carroll Lynch in Anything
The drama is based on the play by Timothy McNeil.Despite Major Star Power, VMA TV Ratings Crash as Digital Engagement Soars
Not even the Beyoncé, Rihanna, Britney trifecta could rescue the ratings for MTV.Sturgill Simpson Slams the Academy of Country Music for Exploiting Merle Haggard
"I find it utterly disgusting the way everybody on Music Row is coming up with any reason they can to hitch their wagon to his name while knowing full and damn well what he thought about them."Gene Wilder’s Genius Was in His Simmering Hysteria
The comic icon could go deep into himself and still be the greatest audience imaginable for his fellow clowns.NBC’s Grimm to End After 6 Seasons
The final 13 episodes will begin airing in 2017.Famous in Love Trailer: More Pretty Little Liars on Display
It looks better than Ravenswood.Celebrities React to the Death of Gene Wilder
"He blessed every film we did with his magic," Mel Brooks said.Gene Wilder, the Original Willy Wonka, Dead at 83
He starred in Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory, as well as many Mel Brooks films.Pretty Little Liars to End After Season 7 — Or That’s What A Wants Us to Think
Eleven more episodes, 11 million loose ends to tie up.Why Bad Moms Succeeded Where Ghostbusters Failed
And why Sausage Party did better than Neighbors 2.
"That was funny"? "That wasn't funny"? "That was fucked"?The 2016 VMAs Were About Artistry for a Change (Beyoncé’s in Particular)
Last night’s show was different because it was almost exclusively about talent.How Amazon’s I Love Dick Captures the Spirit of the Novel
How do you turn a theoretical novel of ideas into a watchable, reasonably accessible show?TNT Orders Let the Right One In Pilot, Continuing the Vampire Trend
It'll be the latest remake of the 2008 Swedish film.Julie Bowen Joins the Melissa McCarthy College Comedy Life of the Party
The Modern Family star will take a turn as villain.Alison Brie Will Star in Netflix’s ’80s Lady-Wrestling Series G.L.O.W.
It's created by OITNB's Jenji Kohan.Black Women Dominate the VMAs, and Pop Culture
Beyoncé and Rihanna were at the center of last night's awards, much like Simone Biles at the Olympics.Eric Andre’s Nardwuar Interview Is a Pretty Awkward 15-Minute Experience
“I feel like I’m talking but you’re not listening and I feel very vulnerable right now.”The Night Of Didn’t Live Up to Its Best Moments
The show did extraordinarily difficult things with confidence and grace while neglecting basics.What VMAs? Taylor Swift Conveniently Has Jury Duty in Nashville
What are these "video music awards" you speak of?