In her review of HBO's Game of Thrones in the New York Times today, Ginia Bellafante argues that the series appeals to men: "While I do not doubt that there are women in the world who read books like Mr. Martin’s, I can honestly say that I have never met a single woman who has stood up in indignation at her book club and refused to read the latest from Lorrie Moore unless everyone agreed to The Hobbit first. Game of Thrones is boy fiction patronizingly turned out to reach the population’s other half." Needless to say, the characterization of the series as "boy fiction" has some women up in arms ("NYT disses thousands of intelligent female viewers who may or may not already like #GameofThrones," goes one tweet, and there are plenty more like it. Io9 has a funny this review is bogus, but Game probably does appeal to boys piece as well). Is Bellafante's observation baloney? Isn't it fair to say that these books, even though they appeal to some women, may be more popular with men, like most fantasy series? Or does that diminish the books, and both genders, in some way? And is describing something as "boy fiction" or "girl fiction" a helpful distinction, or just unnecessarily reductive?
Watch our new series!
Vulture’s Secret History of Television
Who First Said ‘Motherf*cker’ on TV?View all videos
Most Viewed Stories
Game of Thrones Will Run for at Least 8 Seasons, and at Most, Infinity
Jon Stewart’s Final The Daily Show Guests Are All Comedians
Amy Schumer Came Up With Even More Insults for That Guy’s Big Dick
9 Embarrassing Ways Brands Are Responding to Drake and Meek Mill’s Beef
Amy Schumer Is Now the Human Pyramid on Which Jennifer Lawrence Stands
Everything You Need to Know About Chris Hemsworth’s Prosthetic Penis in Vacation
Sean Penn and Charlize Theron Are Living Out Your Worst Breakup Fears
All 74 Led Zeppelin Songs, Ranked From Worst to Best
What’s New on Netflix: August 2015
Kit Harington Is Slowly Realizing That the Next 9 Months of His Life Are Going to Be Hell
Latest News from VulturePro Wrestler ‘Rowdy’ Roddy Piper Dies at 61
"I've come to chew bubblegum and kick ass ... and I'm all out of bubblegum."The Creators of UnREAL Have No Shortage of Options for Season 2
“It’s like a starfish: You cut off a leg and one grows back in another direction."What’s New on Hulu: August 2015
Here's what's new on Hulu this August.Amy Schumer Came Up With Even More Insults for That Guy’s Big Dick
"Did your dick get stung by 90 bees?"Kendrick Lamar Gets Extra Theatrical in His New Video
Has Kendrick ever considered acting?Candace Cameron Bure on Fuller House and Separating Church and Career
And why it will be as family-friendly as ever.Watch Katherine Heigl Tearfully Come Out As a Lesbian in This Jenny’s Wedding Clip
In this movie, her love interest is Gilmore Girls star Alexis Bledel.Amy Schumer Is Now the Human Pyramid on Which Jennifer Lawrence Stands
#FriendshipGoals9 Embarrassing Ways Brands Are Responding to Drake and Meek Mill’s Beef
You won't believe who chimed in.This Coach Taylor Movie-Theater PSA Is As Close As You’re Going to Get to a Friday Night Lights Movie, So Enjoy!
"It was a huge challenge to make this movie," says the Independence Day director.Key & Peele: It’s Hard Forming Your Own Opinion About The Dark Knight, Okay?
Ooookay.Wet Hot American Summer’s Undefinable Brand of Smart Stupidity
Call it dumb-smart, its dumbness freshly imbued with a deep, winking self-awareness.An Oral History of the Wet Hot American Summer Fart Track
Here, at last, is the real, unedited story.Wet Hot American Summer: First Day of Camp Recap: Nobody Looks a Day Over 40
Welcome back to Camp Firewood, again, for the first time.What’s New on Amazon Prime: August 2015
Here's what's new on Amazon this August.Long-Lost F. Scott Fitzgerald Short Story Found, and You’ll Be Depressed by It Soon
"Temperature" will appear in the next issue of The Strand quarterly.How National Lampoon Went From Making Jokes to Becoming One
The strange decline of the once-vaunted comedy brand.Last Night’s Lip Sync Battle Battle Was Fun for the Whole Family, Assuming Your Family Has Tweens
But who won?!?!Jon Stewart’s Final The Daily Show Guests Are All Comedians
This is a good lineup.