American Idol began the year with a woman problem, but as it moved into the last half of the season, there's been one woman in particular whom the show seems to have an issue with: Haley Reinhart. The 20-year-old bluesy balladeer has staged quite a comeback — thrust into the group of finalists with little in the way of backstory, she was a perpetual bottom-three presence, yet climbed steadily into the top four on the strength of scorching covers of "House of the Rising Sun" and "Benny and the Jets" — but comes in for the most criticism from the judges. "Yeah, man, I mean, come on, everybody else gets good feedback," she told reporters last night. "They really let me have it." (At least fellow contestant Lauren Alaina is in her corner: "That made me a little ill ... I'm sorry guys, but Haley has the best voice on this show, and she gets the most criticism. It's just, like, I deserve a lot more criticism than she does.") Even executive producer Nigel Lythgoe is on the defensive. So what is the judges' damage when it comes to Haley, and is there any chance she can make it to the finals?
Watch our new series!
Vulture’s Secret History of Television
What Are the Best and Worst Musical TV Episodes?View all videos
Most Viewed Stories
Quentin Tarantıno on White Supremacy, Obama, and Why He Doesn’t Worry About a Transformers Future
Netflix Is Losing a Lot of Popular Movies but Getting a Racist Adam Sandler Movie
Watch Nicki Minaj Call Out Miley Cyrus at the VMAs [Updated]
Russia Kills Its Only LGBT Film Festival
Hannibal Finale Recap: It’s Beautiful
We Are Your Friends Has Very Few Friends and One of the Worst Openings in History
Bryan Fuller on That Hannibal Finale and the Show’s Campy, Sensual Undertones
There's So Much Crying in This Trailer for Downton Abbey's Final Season
Dwayne ‘the Rock’ Johnson’s IMDb Page, 2017–2047
32 New Fall TV Shows to Look Out For
Latest News from VultureWatch the Frenetic, Creature-Filled Shannara Chronicles Trailer
This is going to be MTV's attempt at scripted fantasy fare.There Are Mad Max Ubers in Seattle Right Now
Valhalla is real.The Highs and Lows of the 2015 MTV Video Music Awards
Miley Cyrus loves and trusts the media.Here’s the Actual ‘What Do You Mean?’ Video for You, From the Biebs
Happy VMA Day!Miley Cyrus Closed Out the VMAs With a Killer Drag Show and a Surprise New Album
Miley Cyrus & Her Dead Petz is streaming now!See All the 2015 MTV VMAs Red-Carpet Looks
Amber Rose wore her hate, Taylor brought her "Bad Blood" squad, and more.Kanye West Made a Shade-Filled, ‘Bro’-Tinged Presidential Announcement at the VMAs
#Kanye2020.The Strain Recap: Fonescu d’État
Romance really accelerates in the apocalypse.Masters of Sex Recap: Since When?
I love it when we get to see glimpses of this Gini away from Bill.Justin Bieber Made an Emotional Comeback at the VMAs
It was quite the sobfest.
"Don't play with me, bitch."Fear the Walking Dead’s Elizabeth Rodriguez on How Her Nursing Skills Will Come in Handy in the Zombie Apocalypse
And what it's like to play a better mother than on OITNB.Fear the Walking Dead Recap: Well-Meaning Madness and Other Viral Maladies
People aren't making sense.Wes Craven, Horror King, Has Died: Report
He was battling brain cancer.VMAs 2015: Your Complete List of Winners
Here we go.Watch Nicki Minaj and Taylor Swift Open the 2015 VMAs Together
The night is still young to reconcile.Here’s Taylor Swift’s ‘Wildest Dreams’ Video
It premiered during the VMAs.Where Your Favorite Returning Shows Left Off Last Season
This contains spoilers!We Are Your Friends Has Very Few Friends and One of the Worst Openings in History
The EDM-laden movie flopped harder than The Adventures of Pluto Nash.The Second Mother Uses Little Moments of Humiliation to Open Our Eyes
If there's such a thing as humiliation drama, this is it.