American Idol began the year with a woman problem, but as it moved into the last half of the season, there's been one woman in particular whom the show seems to have an issue with: Haley Reinhart. The 20-year-old bluesy balladeer has staged quite a comeback — thrust into the group of finalists with little in the way of backstory, she was a perpetual bottom-three presence, yet climbed steadily into the top four on the strength of scorching covers of "House of the Rising Sun" and "Benny and the Jets" — but comes in for the most criticism from the judges. "Yeah, man, I mean, come on, everybody else gets good feedback," she told reporters last night. "They really let me have it." (At least fellow contestant Lauren Alaina is in her corner: "That made me a little ill ... I'm sorry guys, but Haley has the best voice on this show, and she gets the most criticism. It's just, like, I deserve a lot more criticism than she does.") Even executive producer Nigel Lythgoe is on the defensive. So what is the judges' damage when it comes to Haley, and is there any chance she can make it to the finals?
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Here Are 22 Nearly Unbearable Seconds of Megyn Kelly Trying to Dance With Hoda Kotb
Harvey Weinstein Is Spending Time in Sex Rehab Falling Asleep and Telling Everyone There’s a Conspiracy Against Him
Christian Bale and Amy Adams Have Transformed Into Dick and Lynne Cheney, and There’s No Getting Them Back, Sorry
Taylor Swift Releases New Song ‘Gorgeous,’ an Ode to a Man So Beautiful It Hurts
Watch the Real-life Interviews With Serial Killer Edmund Kemper
Former Actor Blaise Godbe Lipman Accuses Hollywood Agent of Sexual Assault
Lupita Nyong’o Writes Op-Ed About Harassment by Harvey Weinstein: ‘He Said He Wanted to Take Off His Pants’
The Snowman Director Can’t Stop Talking About How Terrible His Movie Is
The Good Place Recap: All Aboard!
What’s New on Netflix: October 2017
Latest News from VultureHow to Get Away With Murder Recap: Women in Suits
Why am I forced to do anything other than watch amazing women in amazing suits destroy puny little men in the courtroom?The Long, Bizarre Relationship Between Jann Wenner and Mick Jagger
Maybe he should have thought twice before naming his magazine Rolling Stone.Harvey Weinstein Is Spending Time in Sex Rehab Falling Asleep and Telling Everyone There’s a Conspiracy Against Him
Apparently, he smuggled in a cell phone.Taylor Swift Releases New Song ‘Gorgeous,’ an Ode to a Man So Beautiful It Hurts
Reputation is out November 10.Theater Review: Does Harvey Fierstein’s Torch Song Still Give Off Heat?
Theater Review: Does Harvey Fierstein’s Torch Song Still Give Off Heat?The Better Things Episode That Captures What’s So Good About Better Things
“Eulogy” is a funny, moving, and dark look at a mother who wants to be fully seen.Pamela Adlon on the Story Behind Her Terrific Better Things Funeral Episode
“We were crying the whole f*cking day. We were crying our eyes out. It was so intense.”Lupita Nyong’o Writes Op-Ed About Harassment by Harvey Weinstein: ‘He Said He Wanted to Take Off His Pants’
“He told me not to be so naïve. If I wanted to be an actress, then I had to be willing to do this sort of thing.”The Good Place Recap: All Aboard!
Chidi, Eleanor, and Michael face off against the trolley problem.Former Actor Blaise Godbe Lipman Accuses Hollywood Agent of Sexual Assault
Blaise Godbe Lipman says APA agent Tyler Grasham got him drunk and sexually assaulted him when he was 17 or 18.
XOXOHarvey Weinstein Is Being Investigated by the LAPD Over a Rape Accusation
The allegations could lead to criminal charges.12 Oscars-Race Takeaways From the Gotham Awards Nominations
Get Out and Call Me by Your Name are going strong, while Lady Bird’s chances might be slightly overestimated.Quentin Tarantino Admits He Was Aware of the Harvey Weinstein Allegations: ‘I Knew Enough to Do More Than I Did’
“I knew enough to do more than I did.”What Does Roy Price’s Departure Mean for Amazon Studios?
Hollywood is wondering whether it will mark the beginning of an even bigger shake-up at the streamer.Weinstein Company Employees Ask to Be Let Out of Their NDAs Saying They ‘Perpetuate a Culture of Silence’
“So we may speak openly, and get to the origins of what happened here, and how.”Katy Perry Got Stuck Midair During a Concert, Reminding Us of That Time She Fell Over and Over Again
Awkward.So What Exactly Is Going On With Gerard Butler’s Geostorm?
Jerry Bruckheimer was brought in to oversee reshoots, Andy García is president, and there’s something called “Dutch Boy.”David Blaine Accused of Raping Former Model in 2004
London police are investigating the incident.The Real FBI Agents and Serial Killers Who Inspired Netflix’s Mindhunter
A guide to the fact and fiction of Netflix’s new crime drama.