American Idol began the year with a woman problem, but as it moved into the last half of the season, there's been one woman in particular whom the show seems to have an issue with: Haley Reinhart. The 20-year-old bluesy balladeer has staged quite a comeback — thrust into the group of finalists with little in the way of backstory, she was a perpetual bottom-three presence, yet climbed steadily into the top four on the strength of scorching covers of "House of the Rising Sun" and "Benny and the Jets" — but comes in for the most criticism from the judges. "Yeah, man, I mean, come on, everybody else gets good feedback," she told reporters last night. "They really let me have it." (At least fellow contestant Lauren Alaina is in her corner: "That made me a little ill ... I'm sorry guys, but Haley has the best voice on this show, and she gets the most criticism. It's just, like, I deserve a lot more criticism than she does.") Even executive producer Nigel Lythgoe is on the defensive. So what is the judges' damage when it comes to Haley, and is there any chance she can make it to the finals?
Most Viewed Stories
11 Under-the-Radar Shows You Need to Catch Up On
The Rewriting of David Foster Wallace
What’s New on Netflix: July 2015
Bobbi Kristina Brown Is Awake, Says Bobby Brown
Malia Obama is Interning With Lena Dunham
I Used to Spend $1,000 a Week on Pot Because I Thought Smoking Made My Music Better. I Was Wrong.
Welcome Back, Kotter Actress Marcia Strassman Dies at 66
16 Movies to See (or Not) This Fourth of July
Beautiful Funny Women Are 'Impossible to Find,' According to the Very Un-Funny Michael Eisner
Channing Tatum Is Just As Great at Voguing As You Dreamed
Latest News from VultureLil Wayne Drops New Mixtape On Tidal
The streaming service is continuing to rack up exclusives.Beautiful Funny Women Are 'Impossible to Find,' According to the Very Un-Funny Michael Eisner
"Boy, am I going to be in trouble," said Michael Eisner, before saying something stupid.Malia Obama is Interning With Lena Dunham
She's been delivering coffee on the set of Girls, a glamorous job indeed.Puzzle Master Will Shortz Played Ping Pong for 1,000 Days In a Row
The New York Times’ puzzle maker says the game brings order out of the chaos.Bubba Watson to Paint Over Confederate Flag on his Original Dukes of Hazzard Car
Pro Golfer Bubba Watson will paint over the Confederate flag on one of the only original cars from the TV series.Jimmy's Hall Wins You Over Honestly
It's more Footloose than The Wind That Shakes the Barley, but it has a complicated and serious subject.
This is official.The Sharknado 3 Trailer Gets Political, Sort Of
But does Vice-President Ann Coulter get eaten?Jackie & Ryan Is Like Nicholas SparksLite
The underdeveloped film seems to be missing an act, or two, or three, but the great music forms an uneasy glue to hold it all together.New Video Shows Nic Cage As ’90s Superman
The film never came to fruition, but now we get to watch Cage wear the bizarre costume.
How often do you see a children's animated movie that's this insightful about death and mourning? Not very.Some of the Best Back to the Future Fan Theories
Did Doc Brown actually kill JFK? (Probably not.)Harry Styles Dishes Details on Zayn Malik
Sorry, 1D fans: Styles says the band’s doing great without Zayn.Hannibal Recap: Bowels in or Bowels Out?
The show has hit its nadir with another lethargic, uninspired episode.Wayward Pines Recap: You Dropped a Bomb on Me
Lazy plotting aside, Pines kept things at a controlled, suspenseful pace.Will Shark Week Get Back to Reality This Year?
"We’re not in the business of making stuff up."Eminem and Gwen Stefani Did a Song Together, So You Should Probably Give It a Whirl
Does this artist pairing make you feel weird and nostalgic? Us, too.Diddy Has Avoided Felony Charges
In the alleged kettlebell incident.Meghan Trainor Has Had to Postpone Her First Two Tour Shows Because of a Vocal-Cord Hemorrhage
"I hate everything right now."Jerry Seinfeld Got Coffee With Trevor Noah and Told Him He’s Going to Do ‘Just Fine’
Lots of wisdom from behind the wheel of a very cool Ferrari, too.
Dancing, less so.16 Movies to See (or Not) This Fourth of July
This weekend you can sweat through three outfits, or you can see some good films.Marisa Tomei Is Coming to Empire As a Lesbian Billionaire
Why not?You Might Have Lost the Revolutionary War, England, But Chins Up: There’s a New Libertines Video!
Their last album came out in 2004.Michael Douglas Would Love to Join the Avengers
"I’ll go anywhere they want me to. I like this Marvel family."All the GIFs You Need From Rihanna’s ‘B*tch Better Have My Money’ Video [NSFW]
Happy birthday, America.Michael Douglas Would Love to Join the Avengers
"I’ll go anywhere they want me to. I like this Marvel family."Melissa Leo Will Play the Lady Bird Johnson to Bryan Cranston’s Lyndon B. Johnson
In HBO's All the Way.Rory Gilmore and Izzie Stevens Are Getting Married in a Movie: Your Mid-2000s Slash Fiction Came True!
Gilmore's Anatomy.Just a Reminder That Donald Glover’s Rap-Music-Business Pilot Is Still in the Works
The pilot will be directed by music video director Hiro Murai.