Vulture

Skip to content, or skip to search.

takedowns

New York Times Review Eviscerates New York Times Documentary

In the interest of objectivity, the New York Times thought it would be best if the reviewer of Page One: Inside The New York Times, the documentary about the Times' media desk that's out today, was not a New York Times staffer. And so they selected Michael Kinsley — the guy who made contrarianism cool over a long career at places like The New Republic, Slate, and Harper's — to do the deed. Boy, did he ever. The result is a gloriously brutal and blunt review of the film: reading it in the Times is akin to looking through a fun-house mirror, though the mirror could more aptly be described as a drily dismissive and barely apologetic, rather than "fun." Kinsley writes, "The movie, directed by Andrew Rossi, is, in a word, a mess," and keeps going from there. Read it over your morning coffee! [NYT]