Judging a TV show by its pilot is a tricky business. They're written and produced in an entirely different environment from subsequent episodes. They can be the strongest episode, in that the one or two writer-creators have much more time to finesse jokes and plots than when they plunge into the tighter schedules of having to churn out 21 more episodes on a punishing schedule. But on the other hand, they can also be a bad foot to put forward, because they've been written before the creators know their cast, characters, network, set, or trajectory, and before they have a staff of writers to help iron out weak spots and brainstorm smarter directions, and they can often be stuffed with awkward exposition at the expense of nuance. But increasingly, because of taxing production schedules, the networks only send out pilots to critics because nothing else is ready, so these new shows are applauded or derided solely on these odd, introductory episodes. In the interest of fairness, we checked back in on the second installments of eight of the season's most praised or mocked new series — from Up All Night and New Girl toThe X-Factor and Prime Suspect — to see if things changed, for better or worse, and ranked them from least to most improved.BEGIN SLIDESHOW
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Alexis Bledel As Ofglen in The Handmaid’s Tale Is the Role She Was Born to Play
Caitlyn Jenner Says She Knew O.J. Simpson Was Guilty, and So Did Robert Kardashian
Looking Back on The Ultimates, the Most Uncomfortable Superhero Story Ever Told
Residents of So-called ‘Shit Town’ Are Conflicted Over S-Town
The Real Housewives of New York City Recap: Dawn of a New Bidet
RHONY’s Dorinda Medley on Trump, Her Feud With Sonja Morgan, and Why Her Boyfriend Isn’t on the Show
Star Trek Is Facing Its Biggest Political Challenge Yet
Kim Kardashian Talks Caitlyn Jenner’s ‘Hurtful’ Memoir, Says Paris Robbery Was ‘Meant to Happen’
The Handmaid’s Tale: The Biggest Changes From the Book
The Handmaid’s Tale Recap: I’d Like to Play a Game With You
Latest News from VultureAustin Powers Had to Edit Out Mike Myers’s Butt Cheek to Dodge an R Rating
Instead the movie “went for a slightly more profile version.”Elisabeth Moss Is the Queen of Peak TV
How The Handmaid’s Tale star built the most enviable résumé in television and discovered her personal feminism along the way.A Part of Joseph Fiennes Still Wishes You Could See Him As Michael Jackson
“There’s a part of me that would love people to see it and get into a discussion.”What’s Going on With Frank Ocean’s New Songs?
Frank’s old songs were neat stage plays about the emptiness of depravity, but the "Blonded" songs are more like cinéma vérité.Does Netflix Need Movie Theaters?
With Bright and War Machine, Netflix is getting into the blockbuster game. Does it need to release them in theaters?Riverdale’s Madelaine Petsch on Cheryl Blossom, Defying Mean Girl Clichés, and Calling Luke Perry a DILF
“I didn’t really want to be your typical mean girl or your typical villain.”Good Son Dave Grohl Let His Mom and Stephen Colbert Analyze His 6th Grade Report Card for All the World to Laugh At
Unsatisfactory!J.D. Dillard Is Not Here to Make Slave Dramas
With his debut feature Sleight, Dillard delivers a new kind of hero.Kim Kardashian Talks Caitlyn Jenner’s ‘Hurtful’ Memoir, Says Paris Robbery Was ‘Meant to Happen’
“That was my stepdad for so many years … I just feel like I don’t respect the character that she’s showing now.”Haim Is Finally Back With a New Song and Visual Proof They’ve Been Working Hard
The behind-the-scenes footage is directed by Paul Thomas Anderson.
“Sister, Sister” welcomes Rashida Jones to the Black-ish ensemble.Justin Simien and the Stars of Dear White People on Why Everything About the Show Is a Risk
“There is nothing about this show that’s not a risk.”Empire Recap: The (Nia) Long Con
Cookie, let those two trash fires burn hot together. You are seriously better off.Neil Gaiman’s American Gods Is More Relevant Than Ever In Trump’s America. That Scares Him.
“I think [Trump] is an out-of-his-depth idiot. Who is possibly criminal. And certainly incompetent.”Robert De Niro Learns Snapchat Like the Most Patient Grandpa
Yes, he uses the dog filter.Leslie Jones Has a Wild True Story (or Is It a Lie?) for Dr. Phil
“I got chased through a drive-through by a car. On a date.”Seth Meyers Evaluates President Trump’s 30 Executive Orders in the First 100 Days
Maybe Trump liked Obama’s governing style after all.Fargo Recap: The Inescapable Reality
Who was Thaddeus Mobley?Underground Recap: Macon Haste
Underground is most indispensable when it’s unsentimental.Archer Recap: Eine Kleine Kriegermusik
Krieger finally gets a chance to shine.