Judging a TV show by its pilot is a tricky business. They're written and produced in an entirely different environment from subsequent episodes. They can be the strongest episode, in that the one or two writer-creators have much more time to finesse jokes and plots than when they plunge into the tighter schedules of having to churn out 21 more episodes on a punishing schedule. But on the other hand, they can also be a bad foot to put forward, because they've been written before the creators know their cast, characters, network, set, or trajectory, and before they have a staff of writers to help iron out weak spots and brainstorm smarter directions, and they can often be stuffed with awkward exposition at the expense of nuance. But increasingly, because of taxing production schedules, the networks only send out pilots to critics because nothing else is ready, so these new shows are applauded or derided solely on these odd, introductory episodes. In the interest of fairness, we checked back in on the second installments of eight of the season's most praised or mocked new series — from Up All Night and New Girl toThe X-Factor and Prime Suspect — to see if things changed, for better or worse, and ranked them from least to most improved.BEGIN SLIDESHOW
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
The Walking Dead Recap: The Not So Fast and Furious
Saturday Night Live Recap: Welcome Back, Stefon!
Homeland Recap: The Russians Are Coming!
Where’s the Train Wreck?
What’s New on Netflix: March 2018
Here’s How Carl Dies on The Walking Dead
Timeless Recap: Mission Implausible
Let’s Talk About the Ending of Annihilation
How to Get Away With Murder Season-Finale Recap: Let Annalise Live!
A Fact-checked Guide to I, Tonya
Latest News from VultureBill Hader Celebrates St. Patty’s Day in Cut for Time SNL Sketch
The latest in the show’s “eloquent weirdo reviews holiday traditions” sketch series.Hear Stewie’s ‘Real’ Voice in Sunday’s New Family Guy Episode
Sir Ian McKellen guests as a child psychologist, and they really get into it.Flight of the Conchords Delay Tour After Bret McKenzie Breaks His Hand in a Fall
“I’ve broken two bones in my hand today in a very rock ’n’ roll injury.”Timeless Recap: Mission Implausible
When it comes to historical figures, Timeless lives or dies by its guest casting.The Chi Season Finale Recap: Who Killed Jason?
The truth about Jason’s murder invites more questions than it resolves.The Walking Dead Recap: The Not So Fast and Furious
It’s looking like Negan’s reign is almost over.Homeland Recap: The Russians Are Coming!
“Species Jump” is one of the best Homeland episodes in years.Chadwick Boseman and Cardi B are Headed to SNL Next Month
The pair take the Studio 8H stage on April 7.Where’s the Train Wreck?
The Recovering is a 534-page palimpsest of Jamison’s battle with alcoholism that doesn’t adhere to the typical recovery narrative structure.Let Drake and Migos Take You on a Culture Ride to the ’70s in Their New ‘Walk It Talk It’ Video
Co-starring Jamie Foxx as your host, Ron Delirious.
While wearing all-gold everything.Man Arrested for Orchestrating Bomb Threat at the Roots’ SXSW Concert
“Thanks for understanding,” Questlove tweeted.Horny Old Bill Hader + Malfunctioning Mobility Scooter = Lots of SNL Breaking
Cialis, the devil’s pill.Saturday Night Live Recap: Welcome Back, Stefon!
When Bill Hader returns to SNL, everyone gets a case of the giggles.Oh, Honey! The Will & Grace Revival Gets Renewed for a Third Season
Season one hasn’t even concluded yet.SNL’s Betsy DeVos Tries to Defend Her Credibility, But Can Only Muster ‘I Do Not Do a Good Job’
“I may not be very good on camera, but behind the scenes, my ideas are much worse.”Take Culver to the 1 and Turn Right on Sunset, and Then Watch SNL Revive ‘The Californians’
Whaaaaat are yoooou doooooing here?SNL’s Unhinged Rex Tillerson Is Spiraling Into the Dark Abyss
John Goodman! Perfect!New York’s Hottest Impression Is — Stefon Giving You Irish Club Recommendations
This monologue has everything: Seizure-inducing Malaysian music. Sexy asbestos. Roman J. Israel, Esq.Snapchat’s Offensive Rihanna Ad Cost the App $800 Million