This week's New Yorker contains a review of Don DeLillo's new short-story collection, The Angel Esmeralda: Nine Stories, by none other than the novelist Martin Amis. (Perhaps The New Yorker's usual fiction critic, James Wood, was licking his Jonathan Lethem–induced wounds?) Amis "loves" it. But, more provocatively, he opens his review arguing, "When we say that we love a writer’s work, we are always stretching the truth: what we really mean is that we love about half of it," and then he states some of his preferred halves: "The vast presence of Joyce relies pretty well entirely on Ulysses, with a little help from Dubliners. You could jettison Kafka’s three attempts at full-length fiction without muffling the impact of his seismic originality ... and Janeites will never admit that three of the six novels are comparative weaklings (I mean Sense and Sensibility, Mansfield Park, and Persuasion)." This is interesting not only because it's a highbrow-fun parlor game, but because Amis is implicitly encouraging us to play it with his own work. (No novelist — or person — proposes the above without considering how it applies to him or herself.) We suspect that Amis has already divided his oeuvre into the half he loves and the half he doesn't, the half that matters and the half that doesn't, and is now pushing us to do the same. So fine, we'll play: The Rachel Papers, Money, London Fields, Experience, The Pregnant Widow, and he can keep the rest.
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Futurama’s Writers Reveal Six Hidden Jokes You Probably Missed
Trevor Noah Thoughtfully Confronting Tomi Lahren on Racism on The Daily Show Might Be His Best Work Ever
A Simple Guide to Westworld’s Multiple Timelines
Anderson Cooper Rejected Andy Cohen Because Cohen Quickly Broke a ‘Cardinal Rule’
What’s New on Netflix: December 2016
The Gilmore Girls Cast on the Backlash to Rory and Lorelai, and Their Memories of Edward Herrmann
Elisabeth Moss Leaves Peggy Olson Behind in the First Look at Hulu’s The Handmaid’s Tale
The Highs and Lows of Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life
Gilmore Girls’ Amy Sherman-Palladino and Daniel Palladino Discuss Those Final 4 Words and Whether Stars Hollow Would Vote for Trump
Leah Remini Lectures 50 Cent About the Prudence of Anilingus on Watch What Happens Live
Latest News from VultureLose Yourself in the Eternity of the Gyllenhall
You will not know how to quit it.Jackie’s Screenwriter Walks Us Through the Stories That Inspired the Movie’s Best Scenes
"We know that she was a smoker during her husband’s presidency, and yet she was never photographed with a cigarette."Shia LaBeouf Made a Diss Track for You (and Drake, and Hot 97, and Vin Diesel, and Everyone, Really)
"I'm not a rapper."Pete Holmes and Judd Apatow Talk Crashing, Comedy in Trump’s America, and Sex Jokes
"The show is a tip of the hat to suffering."The New Office Christmas Party Trailer Suggests You Party So Hard This Holiday Season, You Spiral Off Into the Void
*drinks eggnog while driving off a bridge*We Played Entertainment Trivia With Logan Paul and Peyton List
A clear winner emerged.Pusha T on Donald Trump’s Win: Racism Is ‘No Longer Hidden’
He was at Hillary Clinton's headquarters the night she lost.8 Actors Who Flubbed Their Coen Brothers Auditions
Can you imagine Winona Ryder in The Hudsucker Proxy?Beyoncé’s Lemonade Included in Sight & Sound’s Best Films of 2016
Lemonade is declared a movie, and one of 2016’s best.The Hamilton Mixtape Both Reinterprets and Reinvigorates Its Source Soundtrack
The collection is both a no-brainer and a rarity in rap.
Even though the line "I love beauty" never ended up in the film.Kate Nash Rallies Green Day, Radiohead, Sia, and More for Open Letter Protesting the Dakota Access Pipeline
It's addressed to President Obama, the Department of Justice, and the Army Corps of Engineers.Joseph Gordon-Levitt Had No Idea Who Edward Snowden Was Until He Played Him
“Which one is he?”Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Channels the Spice Girls With a Song About Friendship, Rosé, and Violent Government Coups
"Friendtopia" is ideal, but still terrifying.Luke Bryan Doesn’t Quite Apologize for Hitting a Heckler During a Performance
He's very sorry-not-sorry.Chris Pratt Is Cropping J.Law Out of All His Photos, and Honestly, How Dare He?
We thought you were the nice Hollywood Chris, Chris!Amazon Axes Good Girls Revolt, Another Show That Wasn’t Mad Men
Good Girls gone bad.Which Rapper Is J. Cole Talking About on His Scathing New Songs?
Kanye, Lil Yachty, or himself?The CW Superhero Crossover Was a Huge Success, So Brace Yourself for More
Despite spotty execution, the CW’s four-part bonanza scored massive ratings.Rogue One Is Showing That Veteran Directors Still Matter
The increasing involvement of Tony Gilroy is a point in favor of experience.