Vulture

Skip to content, or skip to search.

who did it best

Glee vs. YouTube: Who Did ‘Jolene’ Best?

So! On last night's Glee, Santana came out, Rachel cheated, but, most important, Coach Beiste really liked chicken. Also! Sue Sylvester stole her man, prompting her to sing maybe the best-ever rendition of Dolly Parton's "Jolene." But maybe it isn't? Because we've also dug up versions by the White Stripes, American Idol finalist Brooke White (she made it to the top five), and an 11-year-old named Eva. Can any of them tackle the Beiste? Watch below and decide for yourself!

As Performed By

The White Stripes

If this version of the song were to appear on a Ryan Murphy show, it would be American Horror Story.

As Performed By

Queen Adreena

The gothic-burlesque-saloon-style cover. You know.

As Performed By

Eva

"Please don't take the pre-pubescent boy that I hold hands with" doesn't have the same ring, but would definitely be more appropriate.

As Performed By

Brooke White

Impressive, but Archuleta would have done it better.

As Performed By

Sounds of Pleasure

What man? Where?

As Performed By

Coach Beiste

Was the chicken a metaphor for her inability to express her feelings for Cooter? Discuss.

Photo: Brendon Thorne/2011 Getty Images