Vulture

Skip to content, or skip to search.

who did it best

Glee vs. YouTube: Who Did 'Uptown Girl' Best?

Everyone lost their virginity on Glee last night! It was sweet, it was tender, it was only a little bit theatrical. Still, what would an episode of Glee, even such a momentous one as this, be without the Warblers? So here they are, with a version of Billy Joel's "Uptown Girls" that will make the ladies swoon, and ... wait, who is that slut flirting with Blaine?! Anyway, we've got some competition for them today: a straight-up slick boy band called Westlife, an Australian X Factor contestant, and a couple of kids at church. Plus Elton John. Watch them below and tell us: Who did "Uptown Girl" best?

As Performed By

Westlife

Everyone knows you got to smooth it out and slow it down. That's how you get the ladies.

As Performed By

Angelo Philip

Just a boy with floppy hair and a little dream.

As Performed By

Andrew Lawson

When you're from Down Under, all the girls are uptown girls.

As Performed By

Elton John

From one piano man to another.

As Performed By

Church Kids

The choreography really helps to unpack some of the song's deeper meanings.

As Performed By

The Warblers

Keep those eyes to yourself, Sebastian.

Photo: Rob Loud/Getty Images/2008 Getty Images