Vulture

Skip to content, or skip to search.

who did it best

Glee vs. YouTube: Who Did ‘You and I’ Best?

Last night's Glee featured some muddled messages about cooperation and competition involving dodgeball, something called a "Mash-Off," and Shelby and Mr. Schuester teaming up on a version of Lady Gaga's "You and I." Whether or not we understood what they were getting at, the song was pretty good! But were they as good as Esther O'Connor, Irish chanteuse? Or Vulture's favorite family singers, Cimorelli? Watch below and vote on your favorites.

As Performed By

Esther O'Connor

We hope that Irish exchange student Rory Flanagan is watching and thinking of home.

As Performed By

Julie Corrigan

Lady Gaga, stripped down. Not in that way.

As Performed By

Vinh-Son Nguyen

We are suckers for cute kids playing tiny instruments.

As Performed By

Haley Reinhardt

A mermaid tale is maybe not appropriate for live television, so sparkly bell-bottoms will have to do.

As Performed By

Shelby and Mr. Schuester

You can get as acoustic as you want, but these kids will never get along.