Vulture

Skip to content, or skip to search.

Talk

Did Great TV Ruin Good TV?

Did The Sopranos ruin TV? That's the gist of what Ryan McGee argues in the AV Club today: that because of its "novelistic" approach, The Sopranos popularized a too-serialized standard that's unsustainable and probably undesirable for most shows. McGee says this format prioritizes seasons over episodes — which makes individual episodes far less enjoyable — and that it asks showrunners to look too far into the future while breaking stories — which makes the perfect the enemy of the good. Is this really a problem, though? Are we losing out on promising shows because creators have gotten a little too ambitious? Is the serialized format limiting the variety of what we see on TV — or does it just seem like the format is often used for shows about dangerous, usually criminal male antiheroes, and it's a repetition of theme, not format, that makes "quality" television feel a little repetitive?

Photo: null/HBO