The droning, half-century dirge for musical theater — lamenting its decline from peculiarly American art form to merely peculiar niche luxury good — reaches a shrill pitch whenever Broadway has a bad year. It so happens we're in the middle of one now: The Tony awards couldn't even scrounge up four new scores to nominate. I've already had my little say on causes and effects, so now it's time to turn the discussion over to the people who do it for a living, often against tall odds. This is, after all, a craft that demands massive amounts of money, discouraging, roulette-like ratios of risk-to-reward, and five to ten years of development, on average, to achieve even a failed result. As you thumb through these meditations on the state of the art, consider a saying of the prophet: "What's hard is simple / What's natural comes hard." Here — in many more words — are some informed ideas from four generations of composers and producers about why that is, and how what's hard might be made (a little) easier.BEGIN SLIDESHOW
Most Viewed Stories
George Takei Calmly Dismantles All of Marvel’s Excuses for Its Doctor Strange Casting
10 Strange Stories From Ron Miscavige’s Scientology Tell-all Ruthless
Jay Z’s Reportedly Responding to Lemonade With an Album, Because He Has Feelings, Too
That Game of Thrones Scene Was Awkward for Kit Harington and Carice van Houten, Too
While His Peers Took Chances, Drake Doubled Down on Drake
The Americans Is the Best It’s Ever Been in Season 4
Blake Lively Stars in a New Trailer for The Shallows, Which Is Basically Her The Revenant
The Real Housewives of New York City Recap: Run the Jules
All the Ways Game of Thrones’ Ramsay Bolton Is Way Worse in the Books
Gwen Stefani Carpool Karaoke: She Is Not Alone — George Clooney and Julia Roberts Are Also Here
Latest News from VultureThe Avengers Played ‘Musical Beers’ With Jimmy Fallon, and Guess Who Won
It's like musical chairs, but with booze.Brie Larson and Kenan Thompson Are Confused by Sushi in These Saturday Night Live Promos
She's proving why she was so valuable in Trainwreck.This Study Shows that Gender Disparity Isn’t Much Better on Indie Films
The festival circuit is dominated by men.Arrow Recap: Mother Trucker
This week’s Arrow is all about magic and sleight of hand.Amy Schumer Demonstrates Meaningful, Sane Ways to Connect With Your Man in ‘Closer to You’
Walk a mile in his shoes or wear his clothes, and do a presentation for him at work without being asked to.Aaron Paul Scavenged Gus Fring’s Head From the Breaking Bad Set Like Some Sort of Handsome, Talented Vulture
It lives in his media room now.Nashville Recap: Les Miserables
You win, Deacon and Rayna! You had the worst day ever!Ava DuVernay Won’t Be Directing Lupita Nyong’o’s Intelligent Life After All
Womp.Rolling Stones to Donald Trump: Hey! (Hey!) You! (You!) Stop Using Our Songs!
He'd been playing "You Can't Always Get What You Want," which is almost too perfect for words.Allison Janney and Bradley Whitford Do the Walk-and-Talk, Because We Could All Use Some West Wing Optimism Right Now
Here's a good chance to practice your Sorkinese.
Just wait for the breakdown.What an Iraq Vet Sees in the Recent HBO War Documentary, Only the Dead
Military culture as seen from the far shore of civilian world.A Festivalgoer’s Guide to the Real Cannes
Everything to know about the city: what Cannois are talking about (rats, Russians), where to spot stars, and the best place for a 3 a.m. blowout.Donald Trump Fake-Calls Barack Obama on The Tonight Show to Gloat About the Indiana Outcome; On a Scale of 1-10, How Scared Are You?
Help.Gwen Stefani Carpool Karaoke: She Is Not Alone — George Clooney and Julia Roberts Are Also Here
The No Doubt co-founder did her best emoji impersonations for The Late Late Show host — and, yeah, sang with a pretty full car.Justin Timberlake Reveals New Song Title; Said Song Comes Out This Friday
TGIAF.Magic Mike Is Doing a Vegas Show — a.k.a. Live Hip-Thrusting
Doin' it live, starting March 2017.Black-ish Recap: Wealthy Lives Matter
Dre's insecurities about manhood are getting old. Black-ish needs to mix it up.The Americans Recap: The Pursuit of Happiness
What does it mean to be an American?The Last Panthers Recap: The Day of Execution
This is a story about people who cannot let go of the past.