The droning, half-century dirge for musical theater — lamenting its decline from peculiarly American art form to merely peculiar niche luxury good — reaches a shrill pitch whenever Broadway has a bad year. It so happens we're in the middle of one now: The Tony awards couldn't even scrounge up four new scores to nominate. I've already had my little say on causes and effects, so now it's time to turn the discussion over to the people who do it for a living, often against tall odds. This is, after all, a craft that demands massive amounts of money, discouraging, roulette-like ratios of risk-to-reward, and five to ten years of development, on average, to achieve even a failed result. As you thumb through these meditations on the state of the art, consider a saying of the prophet: "What's hard is simple / What's natural comes hard." Here — in many more words — are some informed ideas from four generations of composers and producers about why that is, and how what's hard might be made (a little) easier.BEGIN SLIDESHOW
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Lena Dunham Defends Girls Writer Murray Miller From Sexual Assault Allegation
What the Hell Is Going On With Henry Cavill’s Mustache in Justice League?
Gymnast Gabby Douglas Apologizes After Backlash to Modesty Comment to Fellow Olympian Aly Raisman
What’s New on Netflix: November 2017
Transparent Writer and GLAAD Support Jeffrey Tambor’s Exit From the Show
Justice League Tries to Lighten Up the DCU, But Droops Instead
Ryan Seacrest Denies Behaving ‘Inappropriately’ With Former Stylist at E! News
Bethenny for President?
The Story of the Woman Who Accused Brand New’s Jesse Lacey of Soliciting Child Pornography
Jane the Virgin Recap: Isabel Allende!
Latest News from VultureExplaining That Justice League Post-Credits Scene — and Its Confusing Cameo
You may not have seen who you thought you saw.Ryan Seacrest Denies Behaving ‘Inappropriately’ With Former Stylist at E! News
“I dispute these reckless allegations and I plan to cooperate with any corporate inquiries that may result.”Gymnast Gabby Douglas Apologizes After Backlash to Modesty Comment to Fellow Olympian Aly Raisman
“I didn’t correctly word my reply & I am deeply sorry for coming off like I don’t stand alongside my teammates.”Jane the Virgin Recap: Isabel Allende!
Is anyone really good enough for Jane?Fox’s New Singing Show The Four Has Found Its Judges, and Great News, Diddy Is One of Them
The network’s new competition series will premiere Thursday, January 4.Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Recap: Bunch of Friends
This show has been planned with the precision of the Normandy invasion.Lena Dunham Defends Girls Writer Murray Miller From Sexual Assault Allegation
“Sadly this accusation is one of the 3 percent of assault cases that are misreported every year.”Mariah Carey Denies Being Queen of Christmas: ‘That Is Not My Appellation’
“I’m just a person who likes Christmas, OK? Who happened to write some songs.”Transparent Writer and GLAAD Support Jeffrey Tambor’s Exit From the Show
Amazon Studios is carrying out an internal investigation of sexual misconduct claims.Project Runway Fashion Designer Wendy Pepper Has Died
The fashion designer died November 12 at 53.
The doc brings you into Jim Carrey’s head in a way that Man on the Moon didn’t.Oscar Futures: Why the Comedy Controversy Could Help Get Out
The debate about whether it’s in the right Golden Globes category has people appreciating the film anew.Wonder Overflows With Empathy and Humanism
Julia Roberts, Owen Wilson, and Jacob Tremblay tug insistently on our heartstrings.The Story of the Woman Who Accused Brand New’s Jesse Lacey of Soliciting Child Pornography
The woman who came forward first speaks out.Jenji Kohan Is Staying Put at Netflix With Exclusive New Long-term Deal
The showrunner has already created Orange Is the New Black and GLOW for Netflix.Marti Noxon Calls Matthew Weiner an ‘Emotional Terrorist’ Willing to ‘Badger, Seduce, and Even Tantrum’
The former Mad Men producer says she recalls hearing about Weiner telling an ex-writer she “owed” it to him to get naked.Darkest Hour Is a Big, Stylish, and Thoroughly Editorialized Vision of Churchill’s WWII
Gary Oldman stars as Winston Churchill in Joe Wright’s fanciful wartime drama.Mudbound’s Dee Rees on Writing Racist Jokes and Directing Mary J. Blige
“If you’ve ever been at one of her concerts, it’s like a therapy session with 30,000 people.”The Last Jedi Will Apparently Be the Longest Star Wars Movie Yet
Prepare to spend a long AF time in a galaxy far, far away.Green Day Expose Trump for the Zombie That He Is in They Live Homage
Both a They Live and Pleasantville homage.