Even before American Idol secured Mariah Carey for its twelfth season, the rumor mill was churning voraciously. Nicki Minaj! Katy Perry! Keith Urban! Kanye West! Your neighbor, maybe! Now Entertainment Weekly has sources saying Enrique Iglesias is not just being considered but has "received a firm offer" for a judge's seat. But seriously, if Enrique can't do it, there's Diddy, Pharrell, Alanis Morissette, Brad Paisley, Nick Jonas, and probably your cousin's fiancée with the pretty good voice.