Vulture

Skip to content, or skip to search.

casting couch

Eric Stonestreet Returning to American Horror Story

Actor Eric Stonestreet attends a party hosted by Twentieth Century Fox Television Distribution at the Fox Lot on May 26, 2011 in Century City, California.

While Justified was pulling for Eric Stonestreet as a baddie, it looks like American Horror Story got to him first. Sure, he got hatchet-hacked by the Piggyman in his season one guest spot, but that's no matter for the new place, new era second season: Stonestreet (who won his second Emmy for Modern Family on Sunday night) will play a killer this time around. Killer Fizbo?

Photo: Kevin Winter/Getty Images