Mud's story begins when two boys find Matthew McConaughey living in a boat suspended in a tree, which made us wonder: Just how often do boats and crazy situations go hand in hand? Turns out, quite often. Almost everyone at the Cinema Society screening for Mud last week had a story to share. Sarah Paulson, who stars in the film, had her high-school prom on a boat at South Street Seaport. "I don't remember half of it," she told us. "I was very intoxicated, as one is [at one's prom]." Even though she was underage at the time? "Yeah, I don't know where I got that liquor from! Some bad person sold it to me. I'm sure some vomiting was involved. And I wore a really hideous prom dress. It was all a disaster." Paulson's prom dress — a tight black lace number — might come in handy for the third season of American Horror Story: Coven, if she still had it and if she gets to play someone magical when the show starts production in July. "Something witchy this way comes!" she cackled. "But I don't know if I'm playing a historical person or a person from the present day yet. But who doesn't want to be a witch? It would be the most fun. I wish I was a witch in real life." For more from the Mud carpet, click through our slideshow.BEGIN SLIDESHOW
Most Viewed Stories
Why the Ghostbusters Trailer Is the Most-Hated Movie Trailer on YouTube
Production For Maze Runner: The Death Cure Indefinitely Delayed Due to Dylan O'Brien's 'Very Serious' Injuries
What’s New on Netflix: May 2016
Jimmy Fallon and Paul Rudd's Recreation of a Styx Music Video Is So Good, It Might Transport You Back To 1981
When Did Audiences Stop Taking ‘Middlebrow’ Television Seriously?
Keanu Review: When Key and Peele’s Cat Comedy Is Good, It’s Soooo Good
6 Supreme Memes of Zac Efron’s Baywatch Face-plant
‘Isn’t This Funnier?’ New Girl Creator Liz Meriwether Recalls the Making of the Prince Episode
Breaking Down Every Song on Drake’s New Album, Views
Why Won’t Hollywood Let Us See Our Best Black Actors?
Latest News from VultureDrake Says Views Sold 620,000 Copies Overnight
But that might be a bit misleading.Prince’s Cornucopia of 2,000+ Unreleased Songs Has Reportedly Been Opened
This is the most exciting opening of a vault since Geraldo excavated Al Capone’s.The Original Ghostbusters is Returning to Theaters For a Very Limited, Very Spooky Engagement
I ain't afraid of no AMC Theaters.Jimmy Fallon and Paul Rudd's Recreation of a Styx Music Video Is So Good, It Might Transport You Back To 1981
So. Many. Wigs.Radiohead 'Knows Where You Live,' Teases the Long-Awaited Song 'Burn the Witch' With Creepy Leaflets
It's been gestating since at least 2003.The Flash Director Seth Grahame-Smith Leaves Film in a Hurry
He won't make his directorial debut with The Flash after all.Will Ferrell and Chad Smith Attempt Another Drum-Off, But in a Classic Rock and Roll Power Move, Get Other Musicians to Do the Drumming on Their Behalf
Who comes out victorious?Yee-haw Buckaroos, The Ranch is Renewed For Season 2
More Kutcher and Masterson for us.The Vampire Diaries Recap: Her Burden
Operation: Save Bonnie Bennett is a go, people!In a Continued Quest to Distance Himself From Jim Halpert, John Krasinski Will Star in Amazon's Jack Ryan
What a dreamboat CIA hero.
They include a "concussion, facial fracture and lacerations."A Brief Look at Will Ferrell’s Brief Involvement With a Ronald Reagan Dementia Movie
The short answer: It wasn't worth the trouble.Of Course the Cheesecake Factory Responded to Drake’s Views Shout-out With a Meme
We made a better one.Elisabeth Moss Will Star in Hulu’s The Handmaid’s Tale, Trading the Sexist Past of Mad Men for the Sexist Future of Gilead
Moss will play Offred.Why the Ghostbusters Trailer Is the Most-Hated Movie Trailer on YouTube
We'll give you one guess what happened.Keanu Review: When Key and Peele’s Cat Comedy Is Good, It’s Soooo Good
"Help it make some money this weekend so they can all do it again."What’s Leaving Showtime: May 2016
Good-bye Evita, King Kong, and Dead Poets Society.Aloha Means Hello and Good-bye, Which Is What People Have Been Saying to One Aloha Billboard for a Full Year
Aloha is evergreen.6 Supreme Memes of Zac Efron’s Baywatch Face-plant
Thanks, internet.What’s Leaving HBO: May 2016
Good-bye Brokeback Mountain, A Knight's Tale, and 10 Things I Hate About You.