American Idol is a disaster this season. Ratings are down 25 percent from last year, and each week the show seems a little duller and slower — and with The Voice doing well at NBC, Idol can't afford to be so listless. What's the onetime ratings king to do? Fire everyone, probably. According to the Wrap, none of the judges from this season will be back next year, and neither will the show's longtime executive producer Nigel Lythgoe. That's still just a rumor at this point, but it is hard to picture Fox willingly shelling out for Mariah Carey, Nicki Minaj, Keith Urban, and Randy Jackson to come back when that lineup seems to be such a turn-off to viewers. It's not clear yet who the new judges would be nor is it clear that the judges are indeed the actual problem, rather than a general culturewide onset of Idol fatigue.
Watch our new series!
Vulture’s Secret History of Television
Let’s Salute the Worst Superhero TV ShowsView all videos
Most Viewed Stories
Listen to Janet Jackson’s Very Lovable ‘Unbreakable’
Miley Cyrus’s Dead Petz Is Hard to Like, or Even Endure
Mark Ruffalo Confirms That, Incredibly, Hulk Won’t Be in Captain America: Civil War
Some Hero Drew Game of Thrones People As Bob’s Burgers People
Why Mr. Robot Is Not a Great Show (Yet)
The Rise of the Sadcom
A Walk in the Woods Is a Trail Not Worth Traveling
Watch Young Angelina Jolie Own This Acting Class
See How Idris Elba Used Instagram, Wisdom to Respond to That Bond Critique
BD Wong on Why Mr. Robot’s Portrayal of a Transgender Character Is Radical