A federal judge issued a ruling earlier this week reinforcing that Sherlock Holmes, one of the most popular fictional characters of all time, remains part of the public domain. The ruling comes in response to a lawsuit filed in February by Leslie S. Klinger, the editor of several Holmes-related books, who refused to pay a licensing fee to the estate of Holmes creator Arthur Conan Doyle in order to publish a collection of stories. Despite the fact that the character fell into public-domain use many years ago, the estate continues to ask those using the Holmes character for money, arguing that the existence of ten stories published after 1923, which remain under copyright until 2023, means that the character as a whole remains protected. The ruling reaffirms the public-domain status of most Sherlock Holmes elements, while also maintaining that anything found in those ten post-1923 stories cannot be used without paying the estate.
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
The Emoji Movie Will Send You Into a Spiral Emoji of Despair
Why Didn’t Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets Find Its Audience?
Mario Cantone Does the Anthony Scaramucci Impression You Asked For, and It’s As Spot-on As You Imagined
In Conversation: Trent Reznor
The 8 Most British Things About Dunkirk
Dunkirk Is a Great War Movie Marred by Christopher Nolan’s Usual Tricks
18 Fiction Books to Read at the Beach, As Chosen by Authors
Seth Meyers Uses Rooster Sound Effects to Censor Scaramucci’s Vulgar Tirade Against Bannon and Priebus
Game of Thrones’ Nathalie Emmanuel on Missandei and Grey Worm’s Sex Scene: ‘It Was So Much More Than Just Two People Making Love’
10 Nonfiction Books to Read at the Beach, As Chosen by Authors
Latest News from VultureThe Personal Reckoning of Tyler, the Creator’s Flower Boy
The fifth album from Tyler, the Creator is a creative and emotional high point that changes the perspective on the Odd Future frontman entirelyThe Emoji Movie Didn’t Deserve Christina Aguilera
Making sense of how Xtina ended up in a post-language harbinger of the apocalypse.Your Very British Streaming Guide to Elizabethan Period Dramas
From the silliness of Blackadder to the seriousness of Elizabeth I.Atomic Blonde Has an Incomprehensible Plot, But the Action Is Absolutely Smashing
You don’t see Atomic Blonde for anything but a badass female protagonist crunching bones and pulping faces in gratifyingly long takes.Twin Peaks: The Return’s Chrysta Bell on David Lynch, Tammy Haters, and ‘Harsh’ Criticism About Her First Acting Role
“I’m deeply triggering for a lot of people and I’ve known this all my life.”Joy and Frustration Abound on Aminé’s "STFU"
The Portland, Oregon, rapper’s “STFU” is just one layered, joyful, and frustrated moment on Good for YouNav and Metro Boomin’s Perfect Timing Isn’t All That Pleasant, But That Doesn’t Mean It Isn’t True
Amid numerous celebrity and musician cosigns, Nav struggles to cement his place in music and find a unique voice.Let’s Talk About the Ending of Atomic Blonde
Ninety-nine red balloons, and almost as many competing spies.An Appreciation of Mark Hamill’s Meta-Casting in Brigsby Bear
Why his meta-casting in Kyle Mooney’s eccentric indie is so damn delightful.Transparent Season-4 Trailer: The Pfeffermans Go to Israel
Maura has a big secret.
“I’m going to fire so many people. I don’t know who it’s going to be.”Jessica Williams Is More Than Incredible
With The Incredible Jessica James, the Daily Show alum is ready to be a movie star.Why Didn’t Valerian and the City of a Thousand Planets Find Its Audience?
The challenges of selling truly nerd-ass shit in an MCU world.The Incredible Jessica James Is a Breakout Turn for Jessica Williams
It’s a strong argument for Jessica Williams as a cinematic avatar for a certain kind of city-dwelling, creative 20-something.Slayer Made a Rare Face-Melting Late-Night Appearance Last Night
Witnessing “Raining Blood” on late-night is truly something.Of Course The Mindy Project Wouldn’t End Without Bringing Back Chris Messina
Producer Matt Warburton promised “a little bit of clarity” about where Mindy and Danny stand.Samantha Bee Lets Her Kids Swear As a Special Treat
“I can get them to do anything by just letting them use one piece of salty language in a conversation.”10 Nonfiction Books to Read at the Beach, As Chosen by Authors
The best beach-worthy nonfiction books other writers recommend.How to Assemble a Sketch-Comedy Troupe From Scratch
An introduction to Baroness von Sketch Show, which stars four specifically chosen 40-something women — kind of like a comedic Justice League.American Horror Story: Cult’s New Promo and Poster Features Another Clown and More Bees
Definitely don’t look and watch if you’re afraid of clowns or bees.