It's awfully hard to tell you the plot of The One I Love without spoiling its essential plot twist, but fortunately, this exclusive scene from the new romantic dramedy takes place even before the central characters have figured it out. Certainly, Ethan (Mark Duplass) and Sophie (Elisabeth Moss) know something is amiss: They've arrived at a country house at the behest of their couples therapist (Ted Danson), and suddenly, their humdrum habits seem to disappear with suspicious ease. They're kinder with each other, as flirty and playful as they were early on in their relationship. And hey, that's what this time away was meant to solve, anyway ... it's just that they have weirdly different recollections of how their first day at the house went, as you'll see in this clip. Can you make sense of what they can't? Put your theories to the test when The One I Love opens in theaters this weekend (or check it out on demand right now).
Trending Video on Vulture
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Anne Hathaway Truthers, Rejoice: She Admits She Faked Her Way Through That Oscar Acceptance Speech
You Should Buy a PlayStation 3 Even If You Don’t Play Video Games
The Existence of Christine Chubbuck’s Suicide Video Has Been Confirmed
Every Episode of Black Mirror, Ranked From Worst to Best
Veteran Stand-up and ‘Comic’s Comic’ Kevin Meaney Dead at 60
Marvel Pulls Image of Teenage, Female Iron Man After Backlash
The 26 Best TV Shows to Binge-Watch in 20 Hours or Less
RuPaul’s Drag Race’s Katya Has a Wild Story About a Time She Hooked Up With a Guy in Drag
The Highs and Lows of Fox’s Rocky Horror Picture Show
Bill Murray Stops by White House Press Briefing to Talk Sports and Otherwise Hang
Latest News from VultureDoes Amy Schumer’s ‘Formation’ Video Finally Make You Want to Sign Up for Tidal?
Jay Z approved, ostensibly.Preacher Co-Creator And Comic Book Great Steve Dillon Has Died
The English artist began his professional comic book career at 16.Deadpool 2 Loses Its Director Over Creative Differences With Ryan Reynolds
Sorry to see you go, Tim Miller.Hey, So Why Is The Simpsons’ Itchy & Scratchy Making A Murderer Parody So Chilling?
Mousetrapping A Murderer.Vince Neil Pleads Guilty in Las Vegas Battery Case (You Know, the One That Involved Nicolas Cage)
No jail time.Stephen Colbert Brainstorms Show Ideas for Trump TV, Reminding You to Call Your Agent and Set Up a Pitch Meeting Now
Chris Christie/Rudy Giuliani buddy comedy, anyone?Neruda Trailer: Gael García Bernal Goes on a Wild Goose Chase for the Literary Legend
More like a very poetic goose chase.Jake Gyllenhaal’s Return to Broadway in Burn This Is Postponed
Bad news for the thespians.Adam Scott to Guest Star and Potentially Make Calzones on The Good Place
Starting next week!Veteran Stand-up and ‘Comic’s Comic’ Kevin Meaney Dead at 60
The cause of death is yet to be determined.
"Sometimes your best is just putting your pants on for the day, you know?"Watch Lauryn Hill Perform ‘Rebel’ on Charlie Rose
This ain't a miseducation, it's an education.Rejoice! Catastrophe Creator Sharon Horgan Has Sold a Fracking Comedy to Fox, and Olivia Colman Will Star
Bad Sugar comes to the U.S. from the U.K., like all good things.Here Are Rachel Bloom’s Favorite Songs and Song-Based Memories About Sex and Death
"The first album I bought was the soundtrack to the Goofy movie, which is a great soundtrack that holds up."
Go ahead and place your bets on Manchester by the Sea and Moonlight.Kanye Made a Very Sweet Video for Kim's Birthday
It consists largely of home video shot by her father Robert.The Rock and Will Ferrell are Tag-Teaming a Wrestling Pilot at Fox
Can you smell what they're cooking? It's a TV show. That's what a TV show smells like.Chris Pine Joins A Wrinkle in Time; Ava DuVernay Settles the Question of the Best Superhero-Chris
This cast is stacked.Donald Glover Is Your New Lando Calrissian in the Star Wars Han Solo Prequel
Your wish came true.RuPaul’s Drag Race’s Katya Has a Wild Story About a Time She Hooked Up With a Guy in Drag
It all happened Down Under.