Jennifer Lopez and Anthony Mackie joined Jimmy Fallon and Steve Higgins for a rabid game of Catch Phrase on Monday’s Tonight Show. The first couple of rounds were riveting, but then an even more high-octane round three happened: Everybody looked like they were breaking a handful of rules — and burning just as many calories in the process; Mackie started yelling like a banshee; and J.Lo employed that most usable-but-impossible Catch Phrase tactic in which even if your hints aren’t working, you just repeat the same gestures over and over, with your butt and a strained face, until your partner either stumbles upon the answer or you lose. We’ve all been there.
