In The New Yorker's fascinating exploration of Megan Phelps-Roper's decision to leave the Westboro Baptist Church, the granddaughter of church founder Fred Phelps reveals that her disenchantment with her family's beliefs sprung from their reaction to the death of Brittany Murphy in 2009. As Phelps-Roper tells reporter Adrian Chen, she learned of Murphy's death on Twitter, where she was active in spreading the church's antigay message. Her fellow churchgoers were delighted by the news: "Lots of people were talking about going to picket her funeral," she recalled. But she couldn't muster the same glee. She tells Chen she "had loved Murphy in Clueless, and she felt an unexpected pang — not quite sadness, but something close — over her death." Seeing all the mournful tweets about Murphy made Phelps-Roper stop and reconsider the Church's message of hate — "I felt like I would be such a jackass to go on and post something [celebrating her death]" — the first in a long line of ambivalent experiences that ultimately ended with her renouncing Westboro altogether. "I just couldn't keep up the charade," she says. "I couldn't bring myself to do the things we were doing and say the things we were saying."
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Saturday Night Live Recap: Welcome Back, Stefon!
The Walking Dead Recap: The Not So Fast and Furious
In Conversation: Julian Casablancas
Where’s the Train Wreck?
Homeland Recap: The Russians Are Coming!
Hear Stewie’s ‘Real’ Voice in Sunday’s New Family Guy Episode
What’s New on Netflix: March 2018
Let’s Talk About the Ending of Annihilation
Timeless Recap: Mission Implausible
How to Get Away With Murder Season-Finale Recap: Let Annalise Live!
Latest News from Vulture7 Days in Entebbe Muddles an Otherwise Fascinating Story
Rosamund Pike and Daniel Brühl can’t save Jose Padilha’s latest.Awards Season Is Over, So Allison Janney Is Dancing With Hot Guys From Now On
A special congratulations courtesy of Ellen.Blink-182 Is Doing a Las Vegas Residency, Which Is Suspiciously Close to Area 51
I guess you could say we’re feeling this.Triple Whammy: Glenda Jackson, Laurie Metcalf, and Alison Pill Unite for Three Tall Women
Albee’s play requires three great actors–who aren’t afraid to butt heads with one another.Lore Creator Signs Exclusive Podcast Deal With HowStuffWorks
Aaron Mahnke will develop a slate of new programming for the podcast giant.John Oliver Wants You to Buy His Gay Children’s Rabbit Book Instead of Mike Pence’s Decidedly Not Gay Children’s Rabbit Book
Buy it for any child you know, or just to annoy the vice president.Fifth Harmony Goes on Hiatus As Everyone Goes Solo
Are they just five melodies now?Watch SNL’s Jurassic Park Auditions for Bill Hader’s Al Pacino Alone
It’s wired.It Was Only a Matter of Time Before Ben Platt and Lin-Manuel Miranda Mashed Up Hamilton and Dear Evan Hansen
Proceeds from “Found/Tonight” go to the March for Our Lives.The Real Housewives of Atlanta Recap: The Problem With NeNe
NeNe is everything that is wrong and right about the Real Housewives franchise.
A dozen cute Golden Ticket holders are on their way to Hollywood.Bill Hader Celebrates St. Paddy’s Day in Cut-for-Time SNL Sketch
The latest in the show’s “eloquent weirdo reviews holiday traditions” sketch series.Hear Stewie’s ‘Real’ Voice in Sunday’s New Family Guy Episode
Sir Ian McKellen guests as a child psychologist, and they really get into it.Flight of the Conchords Delay Tour After Bret McKenzie Breaks His Hand in a Fall
“I’ve broken two bones in my hand today in a very rock ’n’ roll injury.”Timeless Recap: Mission Implausible
When it comes to historical figures, Timeless lives or dies by its guest casting.The Chi Season-Finale Recap: Who Killed Jason?
The truth about Jason’s murder invites more questions than it resolves.The Walking Dead Recap: The Not So Fast and Furious
It’s looking like Negan’s reign is almost over.Homeland Recap: The Russians Are Coming!
“Species Jump” is one of the best Homeland episodes in years.Chadwick Boseman and Cardi B Are Headed to SNL Next Month
The pair take the Studio 8H stage on April 7.Where’s the Train Wreck?
The Recovering is a 534-page palimpsest of Jamison’s battle with alcoholism that doesn’t adhere to the typical recovery narrative structure.