In The New Yorker's fascinating exploration of Megan Phelps-Roper's decision to leave the Westboro Baptist Church, the granddaughter of church founder Fred Phelps reveals that her disenchantment with her family's beliefs sprung from their reaction to the death of Brittany Murphy in 2009. As Phelps-Roper tells reporter Adrian Chen, she learned of Murphy's death on Twitter, where she was active in spreading the church's antigay message. Her fellow churchgoers were delighted by the news: "Lots of people were talking about going to picket her funeral," she recalled. But she couldn't muster the same glee. She tells Chen she "had loved Murphy in Clueless, and she felt an unexpected pang — not quite sadness, but something close — over her death." Seeing all the mournful tweets about Murphy made Phelps-Roper stop and reconsider the Church's message of hate — "I felt like I would be such a jackass to go on and post something [celebrating her death]" — the first in a long line of ambivalent experiences that ultimately ended with her renouncing Westboro altogether. "I just couldn't keep up the charade," she says. "I couldn't bring myself to do the things we were doing and say the things we were saying."
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
Bernardo Bertolucci Admits Last Tango in Paris Butter Rape Scene Was Non-Consensual
Jon Stewart Has a Very Simple Solution for How to Stop Spreading Fake News
What’s New on Netflix: December 2016
Futurama’s Writers Reveal Six Hidden Jokes You Probably Missed
A Simple Guide to Westworld’s Multiple Timelines
Trevor Noah Thoughtfully Confronting Tomi Lahren on Racism on The Daily Show Might Be His Best Work Ever
Which Rapper Is J. Cole Talking About on His Scathing New Songs?
New Tumblr Tracks People Who Are Regretful Over Their Trump Votes
Sorry, Everyone, Saved by the Bell’s Zack and Kelly are Most Likely Divorced
Madonna Tells Sean Penn ‘I’m Still in Love With You’ and Offers to Remarry Him for the Low Bid of $150,000
Latest News from VultureBaby Groot Returns in the New Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 Teaser
Ooga-chaka.Chrissy Metz Clarifies Her Weight Loss Contract for This Is Us, Says It ‘Wasn’t Mandated’
"I was pitched that the trajectory of Kate is that she's going to lose weight."Patton Oswalt Offers Advice on Being a Single Father: ‘You Will Never Be Prepared for Anything You Do, Ever’
"I can't do it. I can't do it. I can't do it"Wale Fires Back at J. Cole With New Track ‘Groundhog Day’
That was quick.Ryan Seacrest Says ‘Things Are Going Better’ for Kanye Following Hospitalization
He also confirmed KUWTK is back in production.Finally, the World Learns What Happened to the Weeknd’s Hair
Don't worry, it's somewhere safe.Jon Stewart Has a Very Simple Solution for How to Stop Spreading Fake News
"Stories that were sent from a Macedonian teenager to grandmothers' email accounts didn't sway this election."Madonna Tells Sean Penn ‘I’m Still in Love With You’ and Offers to Remarry Him for the Low Bid of $150,000
Why, that's pennies on the dollar!Jack White Partners With Standing Rock School, Not on Music But Hey, You Can Still Hope
Nice going, Jack.Bernardo Bertolucci Admits Last Tango in Paris Butter Rape Scene Was Non-Consensual
"I wanted her to act humiliated. I think she hated me and also Marlon because we didn't tell her."
The band was reportedly unenthused by the whole situation.Jennifer Lawrence Recalls Destroying a Rock Formation and Almost Ending a Man’s Life With Her Incessant Butt Scratching
While in Hawaii shooting The Hunger Games.New Tumblr Tracks People Who Are Regretful Over Their Trump Votes
It's happening already.Chris Pratt Goes Full Andy Dwyer With the Best-Worst Card Trick of All Time
Pick a card, any card.Power Couple John Legend and Chrissy Teigen Will Continue Making You Jealous by Showing Off Their Charades Prowess
The film's JFK look-alike was cast from social media.Sorry, Everyone, Saved by the Bell’s Zack and Kelly are Most Likely Divorced
Even fictional marriage is hard.Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Recap: Friend Jambalaya
"Forcing friendships is weird, but forcing love is so romantic. Everybody knows that."Character Actress Alice Drummond Dead at 88
The diminutive star of Ace Ventura and Ghostbusters had a long, interesting career.Your New Favorite Child Actor Is Sunny Pawar
Roll out the (tiny) red carpet.