Before she was stealing scenes on You’re the Worst, Kether Donohue was just a struggling actress in New York City trying to get ahead. As if being broke wasn’t bad enough, one day her apartment caught fire! But don’t worry. As Donohue explained to Conan O’Brien, once she discovered one “magic secret,” that fire totally turned her life around. The name of that magic secret? Lying through her teeth. It’s a pretty great story for Donohue’s first talk-show appearance — that is, if this really is her first talk-show appearance.