Last Week Tonight took Sunday off for Easter, but like the Easter bunny, John Oliver himself couldn’t resist giving a little treat to his fans. In this case, an online video that paid tribute to his favorite type of online video, the YouTube conspiracy theory. All you need is a crazy theory, some Photoshopped arrows, and — this is crucial — absolute conviction that your specific breed of nonsense is correct. For instance, are Cadbury Creme Eggs “a terrible candy that tastes like mermaid placenta covered in candle wax,” or are they a secret tool of the Illuminati? Either way, enjoy disagreeing with John Oliver for the first time ever.