How much do you care about the 1858 kidnapping of Edgardo Mortara? Is that enough to convince you to buy tickets for two whole movies? Apparently, Hollywood thinks so, as, per The Hollywood Reporter, Steven Spielberg and mega-producer Harvey Weinstein are prepping two different takes on the story. While there's a lot of complexity, because Mortara was taken from a Jewish family, raised Catholic, and then became a priest, it's still a little excessive. Spielberg's take has lined up Oscar Isaac as a lead, Mark Rylance as the pope, and a script from Tony Kushner. Weinstein, who has apparently been developing his take for years, is working with director Baltasar Kormákur (The Oath) and writer Jeremy Brock. Robert De Niro is in talks to play the pope in Weinstein's version. Per THR, Spielberg and Weinstein "flirted with combining forces," but their complicated history (specifically the 1999 Oscar campaign between Shakespeare in Love and Saving Private Ryan) made that unlikely. Instead, we're faced with a classic Armageddon and Deep Impact, Capote and Infamous, The Prestige and The Illusionist scenario — or what Vulture would prefer you call a case of the Tobies.
Trending Video on Vulture
Most Watched on Vulture
Most Viewed Stories
The Highs and Lows of Fox’s Rocky Horror Picture Show
Anne Hathaway Truthers, Rejoice: She Admits She Faked Her Way Through That Oscar Acceptance Speech
You Should Buy a PlayStation 3 Even If You Don’t Play Video Games
Who Is Negan Going to Kill on The Walking Dead Season 7 Premiere?
Review: Not Much Light in Fox’s Rocky Horror Picture Show
Two-Time Oscar Winner Hilary Swank Was Once Offered $500,000 to Her Less Successful Male Co-star's $10 Million
The Best Place for Women in Action Movies Is Next to Tom Cruise
Every Episode of Black Mirror, Ranked From Worst to Best
The Existence of Christine Chubbuck’s Suicide Video Has Been Confirmed
9 British Murder-Mystery Shows to Stream Right Now
Latest News from VultureBeloved Veteran Stand-Up and 'Comics Comic' Kevin Meaney Has Died
He was 60.High Maintenance Recap: A Buffalo Smile
"Sometimes your best is just putting your pants on for the day, you know?"Watch Lauryn Hill Perform 'Rebel' on Charlie Rose
This ain't a miseducation, it's an education.Rejoice! Catastrophe Creator Sharon Horgan Has Sold a Fracking Comedy to Fox, and Olivia Colman Will Star
Bad Sugar comes to the U.S. from the U.K., like all good things.Here are Rachel Bloom's Favorite Songs and Song-Based Memories About Sex and Death
"The first album I bought was the soundtrack to the Goofy movie, which is a great soundtrack that holds up."
Go ahead and place your bets on Manchester by the Sea and Moonlight.Kanye Made a Very Sweet Video for Kim's Birthday
It consists largely of home video shot by her father Robert.The Rock and Will Ferrell are Tag-Teaming a Wrestling Pilot at Fox
Can you smell what they're cooking? It's a TV show. That's what a TV show smells like.Chris Pine Joins A Wrinkle in Time; Ava DuVernay Settles the Question of the Best Superhero-Chris
This cast is stacked.Donald Glover Is Your New Lando Calrissian in the Star Wars Han Solo Prequel
Your wish came true.
It all happened Down Under.Daisy Ridley Uses Jedi Mind Tricks on a Wolf; Speculates on Rey’s Parentage
“I went on a moonlit hike with wolves on Sunday at a wolf sanctuary."Leonardo DiCaprio Has a New Biopic to Star In As Music Producer Sam Phillips
The master of disguise will play a famed rock-and-roll producer.Bill Murray Stops by White House Press Briefing to Talk Sports and Otherwise Hang
Why not?BBC America’s Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency Will Try Your Patience
It’s a big dumpster full of ideas and images, some intriguing, others baffling, most rather meh.7 Most Absurd Lines From R. Kelly’s Christmas Album
You better believe there's a song about getting holly jolly with Mrs. Claus.Get Jazzed: Jennifer Lawrence Is Playing Zelda Fitzgerald in Ron Howard Biopic
One "It" girl playing another.Moonlight’s Barry Jenkins on Directing One of the Best Films of the Year
The up-and-coming director talks sexuality, masculinity, and why he can't watch his own movie.This Is What a $30,000 Cosplay Outfit Looks Like
Thomas DePetrillo's extreme costume business started with the sale of his car wash.Every Episode of Black Mirror, Ranked From Worst to Best
The definitive ranking of all 13 episodes.