For decades, horror movies have dreamt up more and more outlandish ways to kill their poor victims. (Remember how Scream finished off Rose McGowan with an automatic garage door?) The stakes are even higher for American Horror Story creator Ryan Murphy: Not only does he compete with Hollywood, he also has to find a way to top himself every year. Each season devises new, ever more creative ways to kill characters off, whether it’s giving birth to a demon baby, having sex with cursed vagina, or being sodomized by a demon with a razor dildo. The only thing that’s harder than enduring these 15 show-stopping horrors? Imagining what AHS might do next.