If you’re Dave Chappelle — running high off a stellar performance hosting Saturday Night Live for the first time — how do you give back to SNL’s cast and celebrity guests at the after-party? By leading everyone in a group sing-along of Radiohead’s “Creep,” obviously. In the video, posted on Instagram by the Roots’ front man Questlove, Chappelle’s karaoke moment seems like a cathartic highlight for the attendants, who were also treated earlier in the night to Kate McKinnon’s emotional rendition of Leonard Cohen’s “Hallelujah” during the cold open. “In a life full of highlights? I’m glad I waited til 5:22am for this,” Questlove wrote in his post. Watch the video below.