Adam Pally and Rachel Bloom are starring in a movie together. According to Deadline, Pally and Bloom have signed on to star in a “dark mystery comedy” for Lionsgate called Most Likely to Murder. Pally will play Billy, “the most popular kid in high school” who “comes back to his hometown 10 years later to find he’s no longer cool and the girl he still has feelings for (Bloom) is now dating the former high school outcast. When the outcast’s mother dies under mysterious circumstances, Billy becomes obsessed with proving that she was actually murdered.” Doug Mand co-wrote the film with fellow Crazy Ex-Girlfriend writer/producer Dan Gregor, who is also set to direct. The movie begins production in New York next month.