It still beat The Office and Scandal.
The producers' opinions of Mariah Carey are definitely shining through.
This could go either way. "Dave caring" is neither of the ways.
"She had a great time but was only going to do one season anyway."
One suggestion: be more reasonable with the episode length.
This week, Idol admitted it had a problem.
It seems to lend credit to the rumor that none of the judges will return next season.
The ones that knock you out, or make you stand up and applaud.
We are so close to the finish line we can taste it, and it tastes like rainbows.
And Nigel Lythgoe, too.
The Following was a bloody hit, but it wasn't enough to make up for American Idol's downward ratings spiral.
Down to three. Finally. Finally, finally, finally.
Harry Connick Jr. was last night's real winner.
If you watched last night's episode, you were a sucker.
The judges went all in for one particular contestant on last night's American Idol.
To counter flagging ratings.
With appearances by Fantasia and Paula Abdul.
We are down to the first all-female top five in the show's history.
Jimmy Iovine really gave it to Lazaro last night, huh?
Ladies and gentlemen, the songs of Burt Bacharach.