This wasn’t the most riveting Golden Globes. Ricky Gervais’ jokes weren’t as biting as he’d promised, and there weren’t that many awards (or movies) to get excited about. Which is why viewers had to look away from the stage for their entertainment: The best, most revealing moments often came when studying the audience, watching how the stars reacted either when they didn’t realize anyone was watching, or when they were absolutely sure of it. Some moments were intentionally funny, some candidly odd, but all worth freeze-framing and preserving for posterity. Click on to see the most memorable of the evening.