• Intelligencer
  • The Cut
  • Vulture
  • The Strategist
  • Curbed
  • Grub Street
  • Subscribe to the Magazine Give a Gift Subscription Buy Back Issues Current Issue Contents
    Subscribe to New York Magazine
  • Subscribe
  • Profile
    Sign Out
  • TV
  • Movies
  • Comedy
  • Music
  • TV Recaps
  • What to Stream
  • Vulture Lists
  • Books
  • Theater
  • Art
  • Awards
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • About
  • Newsletters
  • Vulture Insiders
  • Vulture Festival
  • NYMag.com
  • New York Magazine
  • Intelligencer
  • Vulture
  • The Cut
  • The Strategist
  • Grub Street
  • Curbed
Subscribe Give A Gift
  • TV
  • Movies
  • Comedy
  • Music
  • TV Recaps
  • What to Stream
  • Vulture Lists
  • Books
  • Theater
  • Art
  • Awards
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • About
  • Newsletters
  • Vulture Insiders
  • Vulture Festival
  • NYMag.com
  • New York Magazine
  • Intelligencer
  • Vulture
  • The Cut
  • The Strategist
  • Grub Street
  • Curbed
  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Pin It
+Comments Leave a Comment
jerry saltz
November 25, 2012

Saltz: Make Me a Faux Gerhard Richter Painting

By Jerry Saltz

Share

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Pin It
Photo: Adam Nadel/New York Magazine

I love art, but I hate the astronomical prices it sells for. My skin crawls when I read about auctions, and every year they get grosser. Last month, a living-artist record was set when a 1994 abstract Gerhard Richter painting was sold for $34.2 million. Like a lot of these purchases, the sale was about a collector trying to make art history by spending money. Or big-dick-waving. Ugh.

I want to own art like this, but I’m not rich, and I also think it’s a conflict of interest for a critic to own work that he or she may write about. (Reviews can affect market value.) So, last winter, I put out a call on Facebook. I’d pay anyone $155 plus the cost of materials to make me a perfect fake by Richter, Ryman, Flavin, Fontana, Du­champ, Hirst, Guyton, or Agnes Martin. (Why $155? It’s enough money to me that the painting had to be worth it, and 55 is a funnier number than 50.)

You can’t just call up a guy and order an ersatz Hirst or Richter—unless you are seeking a flat-out forger, but those folks don’t work for $155 and their numbers aren’t listed. Besides, in the art world, noncriminal fakes aren’t news. We don’t even call them “fakes.” We prefer the term “appropriation,” whereby a new artwork incorporates or reproduces another. Copyists lie on a continuum: At one end, you have extremely original artists (Richard Prince, Elaine Sturtevant) who use the old to make something new. At the other, you have people deceiving buyers. In between, you have artists who merely make covers, trying to get attention; slipstream behind the famous; and offer simplistic observations. Plus some who are just goofing around.

A lot of those folks turned up, and three came through. Daniel Maidman made me a peppy, near-perfect Hirst spot painting. The artist Vincent Zambrano made me a pretty good Guyton. (Guyton produces his art on ink-jet printers, and Zambrano’s printer was too small to conjure the surfaces and scale-shifts of the real thing.) Then came Stanley Casselman, who asked, “Which Richters do you want?” Intrigued, I answered, “Any abstract from the past twenty years.” He vanished—then, months later, e-mailed images labeled “Your Richters.”

He hadn’t copied one painting: These were originals in the manner of Richter. All had nifty squeegee sluices of blurry paint, but they were either too pretty or illusionistic or atmospheric. I sent Stanley an e-mail saying they didn’t make the cut, and he disappeared again. In September, he sent new images—so close they freaked me out. We made a date and met at his Jersey City studio. It was clear that he knew this was a lark yet took it seriously. 

The examples of Stanley’s own art that I saw are nothing like Richter’s. They’re highly crafted abstract minimalist works. Not to my taste, but done impeccably. Which turns out to be key for copying: He is a practiced artist who knows how to handle paint.

When Stanley opened his door, I saw what looked like 50 large Gerhard Richters. I immediately had fantasies of getting rich, of opening a Fake Richter shop with him. Then I started looking more closely. All of the paintings seemed Richterian, but many had an Impressionistic, un-Richterian prettiness. Many looked too thought-out. Accidents looked intentional rather than discovered. His decisions stood out instead of taking me by surprise. Richter—who applies paint in scrims, in layers that emerge through one another—controls accident with a physical intelligence and subtle changes of direction and touch; his decisions are in an incredible call-and-response relationship to accidents. His abstract paintings look like photographs of abstract paintings. This creates glitches in your ­retinal-cerebral memory, so that you perceive this uncanny space between abstraction, accident, photography, process, the nature of paint, and painting. These didn’t.

Then, suddenly, one made my heart beat faster. Stanley grimaced. “That one’s not my best,” he said. “You’re wrong,” I told him. Then another struck me. He winced again, saying, “That’s a reject that had been cut out from another work.” Then I understood that only when Stanley stopped thinking he was making a Richter could he make one. We had a deal: Stanley signed his name prominently on the back of each, and I paid him, put them in my car, and drove home.

I don’t think Stanley understands that he could get pretty rich making these things. I suspect he could get $8,000 a pop. I’ll bet he won’t: Although artists say they want to make money and get attention, almost all of them only want those results from doing their own thing. Whereas I love living with my faux Richters, even if neither looks exactly like the real deal. Very close is close enough for me (and as close as I’m going to get). Maybe it’s better: I love that there’s no big-dick trophy-art baggage around them. Moreover, they trigger enough memory of actual Richters that they become real enough. I’m not making a comment about the market or smirking that some work can be reproduced. We’re not creating fake provenances or aging materials: Casselman signs his own name. These are knockoffs, flints that spark, reminders, whatever. If anyone worries that they will one day enter the market as the real thing, I’ll decree in my will that they should be burned.

The final thing I learned is embarrassing, given how much I hate market chatter: I’ve caught the collecting bug. I’ve arranged for more Richters by other artists. Ditto Guyton and Hirst. I’ve got a Kara Walker cutout on order. Calders, Duchamps, Rothkos are all on the way. My wife is worried. So am I. Oh my! I’ve got a case of little-dick art.         

Click through the slideshow to see how Casselman created a Richter in two hours.

*This article originally appeared in the December 3, 2012 issue of New York Magazine.

View
1 / 12 Photos
How Stanley Casselman did it.  
              
            First, Casselman covers the gessoed canvas with an underpainting. How Stanley Casselman did it.  
              
            First, Casselman covers the gessoed canvas with an underpainting.

How Stanley Casselman did it.

 

First, Casselman covers the gessoed canvas with an underpainting.

Photo: adam nadel
Here, in a shaggy V-shape. Here, in a shaggy V-shape.

Here, in a shaggy V-shape.

Photo: adam nadel
Then he loads up a Plexiglas squeegee, which he made himself, with up to half a gallon of acrylic paint. Then he loads up a Plexiglas squeegee, which he made himself, with up to half a gallon of acrylic paint.

Then he loads up a Plexiglas squeegee, which he made himself, with up to half a gallon of acrylic paint.

Photo: adam nadel
Casselman added wheels, so he can roll it down a track. “In the documentary Gerhard Richter Painting, Gerhard was struggling with the squeegee,” explains Casselman. “My setup keeps it perpendicular.” He makes a pass over the canvas, varying the pressure so that parts of the underpainting remain exposed. Casselman added wheels, so he can roll it down a track. “In the documentary Gerhard Richter Painting, Gerhard was struggling with the squeegee,” explains Casselman. “My setup keeps it perpendicular.” He makes a pass over the canvas, varying the pressure so that parts of the underpainting remain exposed.

Casselman added wheels, so he can roll it down a track. “In the documentary Gerhard Richter Painting, Gerhard was struggling with the squeegee,” expla...

Casselman added wheels, so he can roll it down a track. “In the documentary Gerhard Richter Painting, Gerhard was struggling with the squeegee,” explains Casselman. “My setup keeps it perpendicular.” He makes a pass over the canvas, varying the pressure so that parts of the underpainting remain exposed.

He cleans the squeege. He cleans the squeege.

He cleans the squeege.

Photo: adam nadel
He reloads it. He reloads it.

He reloads it.

Photo: adam nadel
And repeats up to 40 times. And repeats up to 40 times.

And repeats up to 40 times.

Photo: adam nadel
Photo: adam nadel
He sometimes turns the painting between passes. He sometimes turns the painting between passes.

He sometimes turns the painting between passes.

Photo: adam nadel
Soon, fissures revealing the colors underneath—“the defining element of Richter’s language”—are created. Soon, fissures revealing the colors underneath—“the defining element of Richter’s language”—are created.

Soon, fissures revealing the colors underneath—“the defining element of Richter’s language”—are created.

Photo: adam nadel
The later passes are meant to bring everything together while leaving some roughness. The later passes are meant to bring everything together while leaving some roughness.

The later passes are meant to bring everything together while leaving some roughness.

Photo: adam nadel
“You have to decide fast whether it’s is finished,” says Casselman. “After twenty minutes, the texture of the paint starts to change.” Then? “I wait till it sings.” And if it doesn’t? “So fucking what? I spent two hours,” says Casselman. “I’m sure Richter’s pumping out ten a day.” 
            -Miranda Siegel “You have to decide fast whether it’s is finished,” says Casselman. “After twenty minutes, the texture of the paint starts to change.” Then? “I wait till it sings.” And if it doesn’t? “So fucking what? I spent two hours,” says Casselman. “I’m sure Richter’s pumping out ten a day.” 
            -Miranda Siegel

“You have to decide fast whether it’s is finished,” says Casselman. “After twenty minutes, the texture of the paint starts to change.” Then? “I wait t...

“You have to decide fast whether it’s is finished,” says Casselman. “After twenty minutes, the texture of the paint starts to change.” Then? “I wait till it sings.” And if it doesn’t? “So fucking what? I spent two hours,” says Casselman. “I’m sure Richter’s pumping out ten a day.”

-Miranda Siegel

 

Photo: adam nadel
1 / 12

Tags:

  • gerhard richter
  • art
  • stanley casselman
  • jerry saltz
  • paintings
  • fakes
  • More

More Galleries

emmys 2020 Sept. 20, 2020
See Every ‘Red Carpet’ Look From the 2020 Emmys  At home and all dolled up. 
By Rebecca Alter
art June 29, 2020
See Peter Hujar’s Portraits of a Long-Ago Queer Downtown  Including a kittenish Fran Lebowitz. 
By Trupti Rami
psa Apr. 17, 2020
A Times Square Tribute to All of Us  Two dozen artists say thank-you. 
By Michael Kaler
shakespeare in the park Apr. 17, 2020
Shakespeare in the Park Canceled as Public Theater Furloughs Staff  Richard II and As You Like It were planned for this summer. 
By Jackson McHenry
oscars 2020 Feb. 9, 2020
See Every Red-Carpet Look From the 2020 Oscars  Greta Gerwig, Janelle Monáe, Cynthia Erivo, and more are gracing the red carpet of the 92nd Academy Awards. 
By Rebecca Alter
gallery Feb. 6, 2020
30,000 Ways to See New York  Drawings from the final year of Jason Polan’s “Every Person in New York” project. 
By Jason Polan
gallery Jan. 31, 2020
The Faces of Sundance 2020  Vulture welcomed Tessa Thompson, Mila Kunis, Glenn Close, Ethan Hawke and more to our photo studio. 
By Vulture Editors
grammys 2020 Jan. 26, 2020
See Every Red-Carpet Look from the 2020 Grammys  Lizzo, Ariana Grande, Lil Nas X, and more. 
By Rebecca Alter
golden globes 2020 Jan. 5, 2020
See Every Red-Carpet Look from the 2020 Golden Globes  Greta Gerwig, Kirsten Dunst, Billy Porter, and more. 
By Rebecca Alter
vulture festival 2019 Nov. 12, 2019
The Faces of Vulture Festival LA 2019  We welcomed Rita Moreno, Elisabeth Moss, cast reunions of Party Down and Community, and more to our photo studio. 
By Vulture Editors
emmys 2019 Sept. 22, 2019
Emmys 2019: See Every Red-Carpet Look  Laverne Cox, Jameela Jamil, Indya Moore, and more. 
By Vulture Editors
vmas 2019 Aug. 26, 2019
See Every Red-Carpet Look From the 2019 VMAs  Lizzo, Taylor Swift, Megan Thee Stallion, and more stars strut down the carpet at the MTV Video Music Awards. 
By Vulture Editors
gallery June 25, 2019
The Look Book Goes to a Little Tina Turner Audition  Dozens of 8-to-12-year-old actresses lined up for the opportunity to play a young incarnation of the star in Broadway’s Tina: The Tina Turner Musical. 
By Katy Schneider and Jane Drinkard
obituaries June 17, 2019
Socialite, Artist, and Style Icon Gloria Vanderbilt Has Died at 95  Her son, Anderson Cooper, delivered an obituary on CNN this morning. 
By Sarah Spellings
gallery June 17, 2019
See Photos of Natasha Lyonne, Busy Philipps, and More in the Vulture Emmy Studio  For your consideration. 
By Vulture Editors
gallery June 10, 2019
See the Faces of the 2019 Tony Winners  Bryan Cranston, Rosemary Harris, and more. 
By Vulture Editors
gallery May 15, 2019
A Trove of ‘Lost’ New York City Crime Scene Photos, Unearthed After 82 Years  Seventy-three prints from legendary photographer Weegee were stashed in a kitchen cupboard and unseen until now. 
By Christopher Bonanos
gallery May 6, 2019
The Faces of 2019 Tribeca Film Festival  Jennifer Lawrence, Zac Efron, Ethan Hawke, and more. 
By Vulture Editors
gallery May 3, 2019
See the Faces of the 2019 Tony Nominees  Laurie Metcalf, Jeremy Pope, Jeff Daniels, and more. 
By Jackson McHenry
oscars 2019 Feb. 25, 2019
See Every Red-Carpet Look From the 2019 Oscars  Lady Gaga, Glenn Close, Regina King, Constance Wu, and more stars strutted down the carpet at the 91st Academy Awards. 
By Vulture Editors
More Galleries
  • TV
  • Movies
  • Comedy
  • Music
  • What To Stream
  • Newsletters
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Media Kit
  • We’re Hiring
  • Press
  • Trademark
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Ad Choices
  • Do Not Sell My Info
vulture is a Vox Media Network. © 2021 Vox Media, LLC. All rights reserved.