vulture tv awards 2015

The 2015 Vulture TV Caucus: What Cultural Insiders Loved Most on TV Last Season

Photo: Maya Robinson and Photos by FOX, HBO and Comedy Central
Announcing...The Culturati Caucus
Photo-illustrations by Maya Robinson

All this week, we’re presenting the Vulture TV Awards, honoring the best in television from the past year. (Browse through our entries by Mike Schur, Mad Men’s casting directors, Kenya Barris, and more.) Over the past month, we polled 135 showrunners, executives, writers, actors, actresses, and a host of other bigwigs to get their take on the best shows, actors, and characters on TV this past season.

The results confirmed that the people who make TV are just as passionate — and opinionated — watchers as we are.

Reporting by Stephanie Eckardt, Diane Gordon, Marcus Jones, Claire Landsbaum, Jenni Miller, Jenny Peters, Trupti Rami, Vicki Salemi, Renata Sellitti, Valentina Valentini, and Kat Ward.

Best Show

Game of Thrones


"Having to wait for the next episode is ruining my life. I’m stuck and I want to binge it! But I can never wait long enough to get four episodes together and then just watch it then. I’m absolutely obsessed with this show."


Silicon Valley

“It’s such a plot-based show, and they do it so well. I just want to be in their room to see how they break their stories.”



“It’s so smart and crafted in such an awesome way. It’s cool to watch a show where romance isn’t part of the storytelling at all. Instead, it’s all kinds of betrayals and work endeavors. I’m really impressed by it.”

Best Comedy


Silicon Valley

“They somehow have done 20-some episodes without having a single romantic story line, yet the story lines never feel stale, even though the area they’re covering — the launching of a business — is so specific.”



“It makes a world that I’m very interested in — politics — so funny. And it’s got such great characters. It works on every level.”


The Last Man on Earth

“It’s unique, and there’s all this unpredictable stuff happening all the time. The scenario is one that everyone wonders about — if they were the last person on Earth — but no one would be as outrageous as [Phil Miller].”

Best Drama


Game of Thrones

“I’m continually flabbergasted by how beautiful the words are, how smart, how seamless, how deep and specific each character is.”


The Americans

“It’s an incredible show. It’s also heavily underrated and underwatched.”


Better Call Saul

“Bob Odenkirk, especially, I love him. The show makes something really great out of having somebody with an out-of-control sense of humor doing a dramatic part. The whole thing is fascinating.”

Best Drama Performer, Male


Jon Hamm,
Mad Men

“He plays everything with nuance and real subtlety, and I think sometimes that doesn’t go as noticed.”

Matthew Rhys,
The Americans


“What he does on the show is pretty, pretty amazing. There’s such depth.”

Peter Dinklage,
Game of Thrones

“He’s just so tuned in — every single episode.”

Best Drama Performer, Female


Taraji P. Henson, Empire

“There are so many layers to her performance, such vulnerability and such strength. And the moment she appears, she just commands the screen — every time.”

Elisabeth Moss,
Mad Men


“She’s got such prowess. I’m so sad to see Peggy go.”

Viola Davis,
How to Get Away With Murder

“It was about time that she got a chance to shine in a drama.”

Best Comedy Performer, Male

Will Forte,
The Last Man on Earth


“Phil Miller does despicable things, yet we love him 'cause he's so magnetic and dysfunctional and brilliant.”

Louis C.K.,


“My mind immediately went to Louis C.K. He’s a phenomenal dramatic actor who uses those skills in a comedy.”

Tony Hale,


“He’s always unexpected. You think he’s going to do one thing and then he tricks you, and you’re going, ‘Oh, you got me again!’”

Best Comedy Performer, Female


Amy Schumer

“She pushes boundaries so well, and does it without losing the sense of humor.”


Julia Louis-Dreyfus

“She's just the best. She's so funny. She's such a good actress, and with amazing comic timing.”


Kristen Schaal

“It's hard to put anyone above Julia Louis-Dreyfus, but she's won enough, so, ladies and gentlemen ... Kristen Schaal.”

Best Villain


Cersei Lannister, Game of Thrones

“I love Cersei, and Lena Headey is able to create complex emotions for a role that could be cartoonish.”

Ramsay Bolton,
Game of Thrones


“He's such a sociopath. He honestly has scenes where you're kind of like — you almost feel bad for him despite the fact he’s so evil.”

Frank Underwood,
House of Cards


"Well, because he's such a villain. He holds the ultimate power, so when you abuse that power, you're the ultimate villain."

Most Important Person in Television


Jon Stewart

“We don’t want to say good-bye, but we know we have to. He’s incredible.”


Shonda Rhimes

“She helped launch the quality revolution on network television.”


Amy Schumer

“She’s pushing boundaries, and when they’re pushed, the effects of that work always trickles down to everybody else.”

Most Quotable Dialogue



“Honestly, everything about this show is just pretty great, so that includes the dialogue.”


Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt

“It’s so precious! I was a huge 30 Rock fan, and like that show, Kimmy Schmidt [goes] so fast, and if you’re not listening carefully you miss half of the dialogue, but if you’re listening carefully you’re laughing hilariously.”


Game of Thrones

“Even if you can’t follow the stories and don’t know what the characters’ names are, you can’t not watch scenes from beginning to end.”

Best New Show


The Last Man on Earth

“I became deeply obsessed. It’s really, really good.”



“There are 80 twists in each episode, and they keep managing to find a way to top themselves. I have no idea how they're going to keep it up, but I’ll be watching to find out.”

How to Get Away With Murder


“There’s more to the show than just this, but the way Viola Davis is so commanding and exudes so much power is magnetic.”

The 2015 Vulture TV Caucus