dark horses

Paul Harding on His Decade of Trying Not to Think About His Surprise Pulitzer

Paul Harding. Photo: Ekko von Schwichow

When Paul Harding won the Pulitzer Prize for Tinkers at the age of 42, it was one of the biggest surprises in the history of American letters. The last time a small-press book won was nearly three decades earlier — John Kennedy Toole’s A Confederacy of Dunces. Unlike Dunces, Tinkers was no legendary posthumous epic; it was a quiet debut about a dying New England clockmaker, rejected by a handful of agents and relegated to a drawer before tiny Bellevue Literary Press paid Harding $1,000 for it. In the 15 months before the prize was announced, buzz from sales reps, independent booksellers, and NPR helped sell a respectable 10,000 copies of the book. But in April 2010, Harding went from being a writer with a small but devoted following to the envy and great hope of every aspiring novelist. The New York Times headlined its profile “Mr. Cinderella: From Rejection Notes to the Pulitzer.” Tinkers has sold 570,000 copies and counting across all formats. To commemorate the tenth anniversary of its publication, this month Bellevue released an anniversary edition with a foreword by Harding’s mentor, Marilynne Robinson.

I played a small, accidental role in the improbable rise of Tinkers. At the time, I worked at RiverRun Bookstore in Portsmouth, New Hampshire, and I picked up a copy on the strength of a blurb from Robinson and the stark white cover. I still remember reading the book in what felt like a fevered trance. Everything around me faded away as I sunk into the “quiet” novel, which starts with a man on his deathbed. I told everyone I met about it, including Rebecca Pepper Sinkler, who, unbeknownst to me, was the head of the Pulitzer fiction jury that year.

Photo: Monica Schipper/Getty Images for Paramount+

Curious about how the award had (and hadn’t) changed Harding’s life, I met him recently in a brightly lit Starbucks in Southampton, New York, not far from a Stony Brook campus where he is now a tenured professor. He looks the part: Holding a paper cup of coffee, he folds his eyeglasses over the center of his V-neck sweater and picks up the story of his career.

Harding had written parts of Tinkers on the backs of sales receipts and other scraps, working it over for years before selling it. His oldest son had chronic ear infections, and Harding resorted to driving around town to calm him down. “The second he fell asleep, I’d pull over and write a sentence at a time.” His only hope was that it would one day become a book.

At every stage of its life, Tinkers gave new meaning to the publishing term of art known as “hand-selling.” Turtle Point Press’s Jonathan Rabinowitz gave the manuscript to Erika Goldman of Bellevue Literary Press — named for the medical institution that housed the tiny publisher at the time. Lise Solomon, a West Coast sales rep, read a galley and urged booksellers to take a look. Sheryl Cotleur, then a buyer for the Bay Area mini-chain Book Passage, asked Goldman to print special hardcovers for their First Editions Club. “It just is a stunning experience to read it,” Cotleur says now. “It gets you on all levels: emotional, visual, intellectual.”

The Pulitzer tends to go to fiction with heavy marketing behind it — the kind that only a handful of conglomerates can afford. Not only was Tinkers born in a one-room shop in a hospital; it wasn’t even reviewed in the Times. “It felt like a win for everybody along the way,” says Goldman. “For the readers who loved it, for the young writers who never felt like they could break through, for the small independent publishing community, for every individual who loves books.” It also helped Bellevue Press survive.

On the day the Pulitzers were announced, Harding was teaching at the Iowa Writers’ Workshop. When he found out, he ran to his former teacher Marilynne Robinson’s classroom to share the news. Her novel, Gilead, had won the Pulitzer five years earlier. “She told me: ‘It’s the American equivalent of a knighthood. It’s your title now: Pulitzer Prize–winning author.’”

“It’s a strange kind of phenomenon that’s sort of there every single day,” Harding says now. “But as a writer, you can’t think about it all. You have to think about what’s next.”

The common narrative about sudden fame is that there are two ways to go — rocketing ever upward, or plummeting under the weight of expectations. In truth, life carries on just as it did before. Harding had already known this, because the Pulitzer wasn’t his first brush with stardom. Prior to becoming an author, he was the drummer in the indie band Cold Water Flat; they toured the world, got signed by MCA. Broader recognition didn’t pan out, but Harding knew all about having to appear in front of large crowds — and having to ride the aftermath of a career high. “You become the protagonist for a little while, but you have to realize it’s going to move on,” he says. “You have to be still standing when it all calms down, and keep working, keep doing your writing.”

Music still informs Harding’s life as an artist. There’s a musicality to his prose, and a sense of intuitive expertise. He refers to something Sonny Rollins once said about practicing for 12 hours a day so that when he gets onstage, the music plays him. “My books are smarter than I am,” Harding says. “That’s one of the things I love about art: It’s improvisational.” For him, the ideal stage of writing is when “I’m not actually thinking up and assigning to it, I’m just taking the dictation.”

That process was already well underway on Harding’s next book when he won the Pulitzer. Cotleur, the bookseller who’d helped boost Tinkers, had also shared it with her Random House rep, which led to publisher Susan Kamil signing Harding for a two-book deal; he was, once again, a major-label player. Enon, a sort of sequel to Tinkers set in the same landscape, follows the grandson of the first book’s protagonist as he grieves for his daughter. Harding says his second novel was seen as more polarizing than his first because it was so dark. “I don’t think it’s as dark a book as people think it is,” he says. “I think it’s funnier.” Because it was treated like a big commercial release, its reception was a different experience, but somewhere along the way Harding realized that he needed to stop paying attention to reviews and the business side of publishing. “My job,” he says, “is to think about art.”

Harding published a reflection this week that sheds some light on how he’s managed to stay grounded post-Pulitzer. It was those early Tinkers rejections — followed by the faith put in him by non-conglomerates — that steeled him against commercial pressures. “Rejection … freed me from thinking about publishing,” he wrote. “The din of the market and publication muted, consciousness itself came into finer, deeper resolution.”

Paul Harding’s workspace, including notes for his new novel. Courtesy of the author.

Harding equates writing to working on a watch. “I’m trying to make every sentence pages deep but absolutely lucid,” he says. He describes his new book-in-progress (currently titled Island) as a combination of Tinkers and Enon, written mostly on Post-it notes — a modest step up from old receipts. Harding was inspired by a story he came across about a racially integrated settlement on Malaga Island, off of Portland, Maine. In 1912, the state evicted the residents, partly on the grounds of eugenics (they were allegedly inbred). Around the same time, the first International Eugenics Congress met in London.

Like Marilynne Robinson, Harding makes his fictional history feel both fully present and fully relevant.  In her foreword for the new edition of Tinkers, Robinson writes: “Learning to write is above all a matter of learning to discipline attention and to enjoy the aptness of language for the work of making a new report about the timeless world.”

While working on the latest manuscript, Harding would wake up in the morning, put a record on, and pore over ten books at a time — Shakespeare, theology, philosophy, as well as 20 volumes of the Oxford English Dictionary, a relic of the Old Testament seminar he inherited from Robinson.  The OED was particularly handy. While writing a scene in which a character goes out fishing, he wanted to figure out a new way to describe the water. When he looked up the the definition of sugar, he found what he was searching for: “There are all these different words for scorched sugar and burnt sugar, and the sugar pleats and it puckers and that sounds like the ocean, so I did this whole description of the ocean like liquid sugar: candied Atlantic ocean.”

Unlike Robinson — who says she doesn’t revise — Harding is slow and scholarly, a magpie of references and discoveries. He’ll go days without writing, but he’s always thinking about it. It works for him. “You’re here to make the greatest work of art you can,” he says. “That’s not pretentious. It’s pretentious to act like you did, but to want to! Why bother putting anything less than everything at stake?”

Nine years after winning the Pulitzer, Harding still gets 100 emails a day. He enjoys meeting people who read his books, but he also loves being a bit of a hermit, and is very adamant about not being on social media. “I don’t even like talking on the phone,” he says. For now, he wants to focus on his students and his family and, of course, his writing. “I want my writing to get deeper and deeper, but denser and denser, and clearer and clearer.”

Paul Harding on a Decade of Not Thinking About his Pulitzer.