It looks like maybe Jimmy Kimmel is getting a little restless after all these years of being stuck in his late-night talk show. On Wednesday night’s episode of Jimmy Kimmel Live! the host decided to engage in something kids these days refer to as cosplay. In what’s clearly an homage to the much beloved Judge Judy, Kimmel presided over his courtroom as Judge James. And it seemed to be … a real case? With a real dog? And real dog law consequences? And also, real dog lawyers! It’s cute enough to almost not be so, so stressful!