When a cranky Kate McKinnon shows up with her cigarettes and pastel button-downs, you know what that means: It’s breaking time! But in an incredible twist of fate, host Paul Rudd doesn’t fall like his paranormal predecessors and stifle his giggles when McKinnon bumps and grinds her cooter up on him for reenactment purposes — rather, he listens to her wild tale back to the prehistoric ages in stoic silence! “‘People’ is such a strong word. You know on the evolution chart, when you see how monkeys became human?” she says of her time-travel experience. “Yeah, these guys hadn’t hit the halfway mark yet.” Trust us, it only gets more disturbing from there.