Intelligencer
The Cut
Vulture
The Strategist
Curbed
Grub Street
Magazine
Subscribe to the Magazine
Give a Gift Subscription
Buy Back Issues
Current Issue Contents
Subscribe
Sign In
Account
Profile
Sign Out
Menu
Menu
Close
Close
TV Recaps
TV
Movies
Music
Comedy
Podcasts
Books
Theater
Art
Streamliner
Reality TV
About Vulture
How to Pitch
Newsletters
Games
Vulture Festival
Like Us
Follow Us
Follow Us
NYMag.com
New York Magazine
Intelligencer
Vulture
The Cut
The Strategist
Grub Street
Curbed
Search
Search
Close
Subscribe
Give A
Gift
Menu
Menu
Close
Close
TV Recaps
TV
Movies
Music
Comedy
Podcasts
Books
Theater
Art
Streamliner
Reality TV
About Vulture
How to Pitch
Newsletters
Games
Vulture Festival
Like Us
Follow Us
Follow Us
NYMag.com
New York Magazine
Intelligencer
Vulture
The Cut
The Strategist
Grub Street
Curbed
Comments
Leave a Comment
Search
Search
Close
MOST RECENT ARTICLES BY:
Dave Holmes
See all their articles from across New York Magazine
Apr. 8, 2016
American Idol
Recap: The Final Finale Until the Next One
American Idol
will always get things exactly wrong, now and forever.
legacies
Apr. 7, 2016
Idol
Changed the Pop-Culture Landscape for Good
Like a big, glittery fire hose,
Idol
blasted a whole bunch of new faces, ideas, and concepts into our living rooms.
overnights
Apr. 7, 2016
American Idol
Recap: The Final Finals
La’Porsha Renae or Trent Harmon?
overnights
Apr. 1, 2016
American Idol
Recap: The Beginning of the End
It will be a crime if La’Porsha doesn’t win this thing.
overnights
Mar. 25, 2016
American Idol
Recap: So Very Close
These kids don’t really have to stretch the way they used to.
overnights
Mar. 18, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Let It Blow
I don’t feel an emotional connection yet. I’m not in love, guys.
overnights
Mar. 11, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Do You Want It This Way?
The FAREWELL SEASON is so screwy.
overnights
Mar. 4, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Now We’re Getting Somewhere
Avalon makes it through to the top eight. My faith in America is restored, at least until the next Trump rally.
overnights
Feb. 26, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Who Can Actually Win This Thing?
After what seemed like an eternity, we finally have our top ten.
overnights
Feb. 25, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Fitting the Mold
I truly have no idea how this works.
overnights
Feb. 19, 2016
American Idol
Recap: It’s No Fair, No Fair
This duets night is killing some of my faves.
Feb. 18, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Solo Night, So Low-Energy
Idol,
you’re weird.
overnights
Feb. 12, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Duet Till You’re Satisfied
If you’re heading to Hollywood, be sure to wear kerchiefs in your hair.
Feb. 11, 2016
American Idol
Recap: A Very Spayshoyrn Episode
The judges choose who makes it past the top 24. Not you. Not yet.
overnights
Feb. 5, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Final Judgement
I am Team Johnson. Or Team Blosil. Or maybe Team Bourg.
overnights
Feb. 4, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Solo Night
Harry and I are fighting.
overnights
Jan. 29, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Hollywood Group Night
Who will survive the latest installment of this “Hollywood Week” horror franchise?
overnights
Jan. 28, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Lines of 10
There is joy, there are tears, there are mothers.
overnights
Jan. 22, 2016
American Idol
Recap: ‘The Most Important Show Ever Made’
Yes, that’s a real quote from an actual person.
overnights
Jan. 21, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Eh-Oh
A “farewell” season isn’t necessarily the same as a “final” season.
overnights
Jan. 15, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Harry, What Do You Carry?
The best thing to do with the part of
Idol
where nothing happens is … supersize it?
overnights
Jan. 14, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Child Care
The Farewell Season Audition Experience rolls into Philadelphia.
overnights
Jan. 8, 2016
American Idol
Recap: Screaming Infidelities
Idol
wants a final Kelly Clarkson so bad, you can taste it through the screen.
overnights
Jan. 6, 2016
American Idol
Recap: The Farewell Begins
This fascinating, confounding, irritating show returns for its final season.
nostalgia
Dec. 19, 2014
Dave Holmes on Top 40 Songs Circa 1982’s
Annie
From “Tainted Love” to “867-5309.”
somewhere in time
Dec. 5, 2014
Dave Holmes on Summer 1995’s Top Rock Songs
This list is wild.
somewhere in time
Nov. 13, 2014
What Songs Were Big When ‘Like a Virgin’ Hit?
Thirty years ago this week, “Like a Virgin” hit the
Billboard
Top 40.
somewhere in time
Oct. 28, 2014
Does Taylor Swift’s
1989
Sound Like 1989?
Not really.
somewhere in time
Oct. 24, 2014
Dave Holmes on the Songs of January 1998
So many fish-eye lenses.
somewhere in time
Oct. 10, 2014
What Songs Were Popular 23 Years Ago, When Nirvana’s
Nevermind
Debuted?
Hint: Someone’s funky bunch is involved.
somewhere in time
Oct. 8, 2014
21 More
Now That’s What I Call Music!
Flops
Part two in a two-part investigation into the ubiquitous compilation series’ biggest misfires.
somewhere in time
Sept. 19, 2014
The Least Successful Tracks From 20
Now That’s What I Call Music!
Albums
Part one in an ongoing investigation into the ubiquitous compilation series.
1994-95 tv week
Sept. 5, 2014
The
My So-Called Life
Soundtrack Is the Best
Cue the Buffalo Tom.
vulture compendiums
Sept. 3, 2014
The 1994–95 TV Season’s New Shows, Graded by Their Theme Songs
From
Muscle
to
My So-Called Life
, and everything in between.
1994-95 tv week
Sept. 2, 2014
Let’s Discuss the Totally Bananas Fifth Season of
Beverly Hills, 90210
Plus: a track-by-track assessment of
Beverly Hills, 90210: The College Years
.
somewhere in time
Aug. 15, 2014
25 Hugely Popular Soundtracks That Somehow Never Hit No. 1
Whatever. These all hit No. 1 in our world.
somewhere in time
Aug. 1, 2014
It’s Time to Revisit All 38 Soundtracks to Hit No. 1 Since
Purple Rain
Yes, the
Howard Stern’s Private Parts
soundtrack was a No. 1 album.
somewhere in time
July 24, 2014
It Is Absolutely Time to Reexamine Last Week’s Top 40 Singles Chart
Dave Holmes explores the dizzying terrain of
just seven days ago
.
somewhere in time
July 14, 2014
Revisiting Hit Music Circa
When Harry Met Sally
You’ll have what Martika’s having.
somewhere in time
July 3, 2014
Dave Holmes on the Hits of July 1983
“And here’s Diana Ross wearing a glittering fuchsia catsuit in her 1983 Central Park concert.”
somewhere in time
June 17, 2014
Dave Holmes on Casey Kasem’s Final Top 40
Casey Kasem was never cool, and that’s why Casey Kasem was the coolest guy in the history of radio.
somewhere in time
June 12, 2014
Let’s Revisit Ace of Base, Warren G, and Other Summer Songs From 1994
What was playing on your car stereo as you drove to see
The Lion King
and in the famous white Ford Bronco carrying O.J. Simpson?
somewhere in time
June 5, 2014
Dave Holmes Revisits ‘U Can’t Touch This,’ ‘Poison,’ and Other 1990 Jams
What songs were popular 24 years ago, when
Mariah Carey
dropped?
somewhere in time
May 29, 2014
Dave Holmes Pays Respect to ‘Rappin’ Rodney’ and 99 Other Hits From 1984
Which of these top 100 songs from January 28, 1984, deserves more respect? Judge Dave Holmes presides over the case.
overnights
May 22, 2014
American Idol
Season 13 Finale Recap: We Did It!
American Idol
season 13 limped across the finish line like a poorly trained marathoner.
overnights
May 21, 2014
American Idol
Recap: Puncher vs. Boxer
Dave Holmes heads to night one of the
American Idol
finals.
somewhere in time
May 19, 2014
Dave Holmes Revisits ‘Closing Time,’ ‘Sex and Candy,’ and Other May 1998 Hits
This is what we were listening to 16 years ago, when that other
Godzilla
movie was released.
overnights
May 16, 2014
American Idol
Recap: Take Me Home
Can we vote to keep Georgia the puppy and send everyone else home?
overnights
May 15, 2014
American Idol
Recap: 500 Episodes of Bummer
It’s the 500th episode! What an accomplishment! But seriously, this show is killing us.
overnights
May 9, 2014
American Idol
Recap: We Are Not A-Meused
God dammit, Randy Jackson.
More Articles